Just saying any good Jedi worth his salt has some kind of dramatic experience happen to him or her usually involving the death of a loved one. The aftermath of this death is usually a good point to intruduce the temptation of The Dark Side. Know I like Kira but I think it would make my JK's personal story alot better if she died in some super Dramatic way. What do you guys think?

1) I haven't romanced Kira, since I went full Light Side: my character should be able to resist any temptation of the Dark Side arisen from her loss, standing firm in the Jedi Code.

2) Some Jedi Knights hate Kira and would only say "good riddance" to her death.

3) Chapter 2 ending spoiler:

your hold on the Light is stronger just like any redeemed Jedi.

 

These facts imply that story-wise, the death of Kira shouldn't necessarily lead to a fall to the Dark Side, rather to many possible and different consequences (from a fall to the Dark Side to nothing at all). Many could be happy/find it interesting but many would also be angry at BioWare.

The fact that many Jedi have seen a loved one's demise doesn't mean most them must.

The way the game is structured today, I don't think it allows for Companions to be lost, "deleted".

Edited October 26, 2012 by Lurtzello

This would only work if you allowed this situation for each different class and a single of their companions. A similar situation where you could kill off one of them, however you'd have to have either a different character that would join you in replacement of that character if you kill them, or the replacement character just be a bland regular average joe with no depth, maybe even a droid.

 

Other than that, it would be awesome for the story to go down a little more of a dynamic route, linearity is this game's biggest hurdle.

I don't use her so I couldn't care less if she's dead.

I don't want her to die, but I would agree that someone needs to die. It makes the story more dramatic, real, and gripping. Writers need to realize this. Also - a death should be unexpected.

So a 'That was for Thane you son of a *****!' moment? cool, I'd be on board for that.

Sorry, but its not going to happen. Pre-launch (I think) SW's had a chance to

and there was a huge uproar over that. They would kill someone relavent to the story off, but not a companion. Especially a companion that some people (me) have romanced.

Just saying any good Jedi worth his salt has some kind of dramatic experience happen to him or her usually involving the death of a loved one. The aftermath of this death is usually a good point to intruduce the temptation of The Dark Side. Know I like Kira but I think it would make my JK's personal story alot better if she died in some super Dramatic way. What do you guys think?

 

Sacrilege!!!

No Kira no, pleeeease

if necesessary, I think sergent Rusk is a good alternative:rolleyes:

No Kira no, pleeeease

if necesessary, I think sergent Rusk is a good alternative:rolleyes:

 

SGT Rusk is the ONLY one who should die in the JK's crew. He's completely useless as it is.

I would rather have my ship droid die. Edited October 26, 2012 by Tomb-Stone

I would rather have my ship droid die.

 

Who wouldn't?

Who wouldn't?

 

Exactly!

Who wouldn't?

 

Makes you wonder why these guys want to throw Kiera under the bus.

SGT Rusk is the ONLY one who should die in the JK's crew. He's completely useless as it is.

 

and how would that make the story more dramatic like the op wants?

 

i dont think he hates kira but he wasnt a noooooo moment in the game.

 

 

 

1) I haven't romanced Kira, since I went full Light Side: my character should be able to resist any temptation of the Dark Side arisen from her loss, standing firm in the Jedi Code.

2) Some Jedi Knights hate Kira and would only say "good riddance" to her death.

3) Chapter 2 ending spoiler:

Having fallen to the Dark Side once already

your hold on the Light is stronger just like any redeemed Jedi.

 

These facts imply that story-wise, the death of Kira shouldn't necessarily lead to a fall to the Dark Side, rather to many possible and different consequences (from a fall to the Dark Side to nothing at all). Many could be happy/find it interesting but many would also be angry at BioWare.

The fact that many Jedi have seen a loved one's demise doesn't mean most them must.

The way the game is structured today, I don't think it allows for Companions to be lost, "deleted".

 

This is not an accurate evaluation of the Chapter 2 ending

 

 

 

and how would that make the story more dramatic like the op wants?

 

i dont think he hates kira but he wasnt a noooooo moment in the game.

 

 

which personally i did when orgus died i shouted nooooooooooooooooo so loud that i work my partner up thinking something was wrong.

 

Well, your spoiler is the best NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO moment in the game already. Why have another one? Especially one involving Kira. She's the ONLY LI for the male Knight, and she's awesome!

Am I the only one that gets the feeling that Rusk would actually be happy about dying? He's not suicidal by any means but he does have no concept of his own mortality and does seem the type to want to die going up in a huge blaze of glory.

I missed out on flirting with her entirely, thus I actually WANT her to live.

If Kira died, I would stop playing my JK. She is hands-down my favourite companion in the game.

Next comes Vette, but she's still a long ways off.

Just saying any good Jedi worth his salt has some kind of dramatic experience happen to him or her usually involving the death of a loved one. The aftermath of this death is usually a good point to intruduce the temptation of The Dark Side. Know I like Kira but I think it would make my JK's personal story alot better if she died in some super Dramatic way. What do you guys think?

So...

 

 

Why must she die ? Leave her alone , shes the only Romance Female or Only Female for the Male JK gets !!!!

I like Kira... tho if they brought back the option to kill Quinn I'd do it every time... as it stands now I have a sith pureblood warrior I made and use solely for the purpose of smacking him so he cries

i think if they would do something like this it would have to be you pick which one goes on a sucide mission i probally go with T7 or kira those are the 2 compaions i don't care for at all