I like Scourge much better than selfish Doc also. Scourge's talks about how he doesn't really feel anymore and about his faint memories of his last lover are more compelling than Doc whining about not being famous.
Well, that was interesting. I found Doc to be one of the best BioWare romances that I have done in quite some time. Different people like different things as always. Actually like him better than Malavi Quinn which I found a little surprising. Quinn is sweet, but a little on the boring side for me.