this is a NiM EC + HM TFB progression thread so kills from both raids, dates and time are taken into account. just because a guild killed something 3rd doesn't mean they are 3rd.
So you're using some sort of arbitrary scoring system to rank guilds? That's not detailed anywhere in your original post... How are you scoring things to rank guilds then?
I could be wrong, but haven't all the rest of the progression threads on this server been ranked in chronological order based on killing the last boss? It sure seems like you're trying to change the rules mid-game.