Completely agree there.
In my opinion 2 for both (normally).
1 = Model physique (tall & thin). I like on the selection screen, but it looks too anorexic from some angles in game
2 = Healthy athletic female, my standard preference now
3 = Amazon. Where #2 does volleyball, #3 does wrestling or gridiron
4 = Curvy. It's just #2 with padding.
1 = Teenager. Or potentially little asian guy or little old man with the right looks.
2 = Healthy athletic male, my standard preference
3 = Duke Nukem, FPS action hero build.
4 = Depends on race for me. If they're white, they normally look fat to me. If they're darker skinned I think Samoan/Sumo (muscle with padding).
2s all round!