I completely agree on the Bane place in your list, and Deceived as well. And considering this to be your introduction to the characters I can understand why you may like the Revan book better than myself, with that in mind I can understand how its the last on your list. Also, you should give the Kotor games a shot, if you feel so inclined.

I kinda liked the Scourge part also. But, I didn't buy the book to find out how Scourge became who he is. I bought it to find out the secret of Revans final days. In regards to the roflstomping, I too have seen Revan fans up in arms over this, however I'm not upset that he lost, I'm upset that Drew, the writer of the Bane trilogy which to this day is my favorite of any star wars books, should've been more than capable of writing a better story, a gripping tale putting all readers on edge. I didn't want a curb stomp from either side, regardless not once in the entire fight did I feel they had a chance at winning. He dropped the ball, he had Revan and Meetra, and the way he handled them, it almost seemed like they were an afterthought, as if he wrote the story and then remembered he had to include those two. Never mind anyone who played them, they have canon history, they each made decisions that shaped the galaxy, and Drew just threw them away. The writing these characters started with was top notch, what they ended with was, sad. The Emperor didnt defeat these two, Drew did.

While I understand what you're saying the book is called Revan, it's misleading to take a big part of the books focus off the title character, regardless of his role in the game, the book is called Revan, people who know the character buy it to find out what happened with him, and people who didnt play the KOTOR games likely expect the focus of the book to be on this guy in the mask, but I feel we can both agree, We were deceived Oh for the record, loved the Deceived book.

Lieutenant Crunch

The characters of Meetra and Revan left no impression on me like they should have, especially given the back stories they already had, Drew made Revan and Meetra boring more times than not. Now I may be wrong, it's been some time since I read the book. But, going in I was expecting a story about Revan, what I remember getting was, some revan, some Exile, lot of Scourge, Which really, to be fair the book could have been given a different name, a more fitting name, because, while yes the book tells us what happens to Revan, it was clearly not the focus. I didn't want invincible god Revan, but I didn't want boring either. I'm no fanboy but the book was just poorly put together and dragged more times than I was comfortable with, and it was rather forgettable.

I can dream.

True, but Disney has always seemed the safer of the two. I can't recall anything as demented as Courage the Cowardly dog on Disney. For the record, I am not intending any hate towards Disney. Though I refuse to see Mickey Mouse as anything other than a Dark Lord of the Sith.

You are right about that. It's my fault, I should have been more clear. I meant to say Disney Channel. Isn't Disney XD geared towards 13 and under something like that? Those movies you mentioned, to my knowledge hasn't been aired on Disney channel.

The trailer doesn't look awful, I kinda like it. But this is Disney...now I admit, I don't watch Disney, but most networks that market to the younger audiences as far as I know, follow the trope, Never say die to awkward lengths. This is taking place between 3 and 4, and I say this without having watched all the clone wars (just starting) but there is no such thing as a kid friendly war, isn't this about Rebellion? I have this picture in my mind, that Disney is the worst about death in todays world. That being said, I'm morbidly curious about how they are going to go about it.

This sounds accurate, however I'm holding out hope that TFU will be upheld, It's not impossible. I used to bullseye womp rats in my T-16 back home, they're not much bigger than two meters. As I recall hearing the Rebellion wasn't a big thing for some time, it was a lot of rebel factions fighting the Empire the best they could. Whcih means they very well could use the Starkiller story. I like what I saw in the trailer for Rebels, and just think, Starkiller vs Kanan. And they could go into Starkillers past more with the new series, it has potential, whether or not they go for it, and they probably will not, is completely on them.

Do you think that the Rakata would have done better against the Reapers?

This sounds awful. But I have a biased dislike for Lego/ starwars anything.

While you are correct, you can switch anyone, the topic is Sith and Protheans. No disrespect intended, but I'm not sure if them having things in common is relevant, I mean yeah they are rather different, but that's the point. Though they do have the whole "extinct race thing" in common. But while we're on it, who else could we switch the Sith with?

The Sith would have a thing for seafood. I think the genocide of the Sith would take longer.

I agree to a point. Like if they made a "what if" for some ME races. But I wouldn't really want them in Star wars cannon.