A lot of people seem to either love it or hate it, I actually think it's a great film. It's my third favourite film behind ESB and A New Hope. The acting and script is a little off at times but the film for the most part is great fun.

 

What's your opinion on it?

One of the best SW episodes in my opinion, only ESB is behind it. I still remember the first time i watched ROTS, it was really unforgettable.

Garbage, like the other two prequels. Perhaps slightly better, I know it's the one people seem to like the most.

Probably one of the better prequels, which isn't saying a lot. I love some scenes (e.g. the one with Palpatine & Anakin at the opera) but the rest of the film just wasn't really that great (acting, writing, make up, CGI etc). Actually that's probably how I feel about TPM as well. AotC had no redeeming qualities.

Probably one of the better prequels, which isn't saying a lot. I love some scenes (e.g. the one with Palpatine & Anakin at the opera) but the rest of the film just wasn't really that great (acting, writing, make up, CGI etc). Actually that's probably how I feel about TPM as well. AotC had no redeeming qualities.

 

Agreed

I liked it, but then again I liked all of the movies so...../shrugs.

I liked it, but then again I liked all of the movies so...../shrugs.

 

While I like the OT more, I do like the PT as well. As for RotS it supplanted RotJ as my third favorite; ANH will ALWAYS be my favorite, followed by ESB.

While I like the OT more, I do like the PT as well. As for RotS it supplanted RotJ as my third favorite; ANH will ALWAYS be my favorite, followed by ESB.

 

I can't gauge which set I like better, so I actually just look at it as one huge movie really.

Edited December 17, 2012 by Wolfninjajedi

Decent enough, but I looked for very different things in that movie than others, regardless I prefer the novelizations to the films, just as I prefer the early EU to the G-canon.