Why NO KILL option on Ashara?

Just like Another said back some time ago. "Now We're the Companion in our own story". We nolonger make any decisions, you do the actions, get the results (They want you to have) and go on with what those (Former) companions have laid out. Nobody is actually in charge of their Character(s) anymore; not since KotFE started. As for Ashara this is actually Not how the Hieratical structure works. The S.I. is in the process of being Usurped and can do nothing to stop it. Usurped by the twit no less. Those that didn't like her, too bad she stays, those that didn't like Arcann, too bad he stays too and don't forget, nearly everybody else has dropped off , been killed (by you or other people). Just stuck .Once again Everybody in the game has to go on because only some wanted it. Great job Boyd. your writing and lack of forethought has created this.

Yeah they could. Pc could kill the wife, children, release the father and take valk solo. Meaning even if they did decide to opt in for help, they still had the capacity to go toe to toe with one of the, if not the, greatest power in the galaxy.

She walked away while SI just stood there, though. Basically Inquisitor let her go, whether the player wanted them to or not. Imo the issue is not with how Ashara was written in this scene, it's how SI was.

I never realized that my LI was hated so much by Inquisitor mains! I for one am glad she's back, I'm just pissed that we waited 2yrs and were given a short cutscene! ***! That aside, as others have already stated there's really nothing wrong with giving people the option to kill off their companions, it's not like most of old companions are even that relevant to the story anyways. Bioware seems hellbent on making sure that the majority of OG comps are just background characters with minimal dialogue.

I do admit however that I was slightly annoyed that she considers herself equal to my Darth Occlus, that statement is frankly ridiculous! I ate 4 *********** ghosts for christ sake! Short of absorbing ghosts herself or using some sort of ancient lightside ritual there's no way that she should be equal to any Inquisitor in terms of power. Although I don't consider the statement an offense worthy of death, hell I've never cared for playing as a full blown DSV....most of the DS choices our characters are able to make just feel very.....chaotic stupid I guess?

I'm Glad the L.S. Inq's got their "Love Interest" back I'm sure like all others they missed them (Virtually). Its the "Way It was Written" that *Again drove the story into the Corner/ Dead End. They possibly "Were Listening" about "Any "Kill/ No Kill Option" effectively deadens that comp to everybody (Except Arcann) so they try a different approach but again, They've really Mucked up the entire scene/Character. The "Sith. Inquisitor" is "By Default" a Sith DS character although "Many play the LS side". Its Good the Real SWTOR was able to provide for such Wide Range of styles however This,..Now,.. plays only well to the 1 LS Inq. looking for a friends return or 2 DS Inq. that cares nothing about the Sith culture. They catered to a smaller group again over the default and higher percentage (Pleased a few while P*****g off many). Who makes these decisions and who okay's them?

P.S. Is the New Ashara one of the "Pod people"?

Well, I'm happy for you that you got your comp back after two years. Did you even get a cut scene with a kiss between you? I've never liked her, so I never ventured to see how the other half live...not even on youtube. I do appreciate that you can see how darksiders would be annoyed. You're not wrong about the chaotic stupid...when I play my darksider, I tend to choose dark, unless it's ridiculous, or stupid, then I take the hit and work off my points with missions.

I wish they'd take the time to write some intelligent evil, it does exist, not every dark evil character is frothing at the mouth mad.





I don't understand how they arrive at the decisions they do either sometimes. I am curious though, is she a pod person? Anyone?