Kaggath Tournament Finals - Ascending Empire vs Droid Supremacy

It came from a random thought that crossed my mind and I felt the need to share?

It hadn't been mentioned before, so I mentioned it.

Other than that is there a reason for your outrage? And did I say AE counter intelligence > DS underworld? This is a simply early warning system for the AE for tracking fleet movements, I fail to see what the issue is here.

Wasn't referring to that Beni, I was referring to StarSquirrel in his big long reply where he kept mention *AE Counter Intelligence > Underworld*

The signal ships are perfectly plausible and an all around good idea.

Edit: Whenever I try and quote what someone said inside a quote so they could easily respond to it, I tend to have issues with the color so it is harder to tell apart who said what. The post I mean is post 576.

Edit: To counter the all clear signals it is possible that they could be boarded before the alarm could be raised. Likely boarded by Gonzoti ships due to their speed and size, and they likely would be acting as scouts for the rest of the fleet. Also, where would these vessels be taken from?

Yeah as before all I'm saying is that the tech rule doesn't apply, so we go straight to a direct ship-to-ship comparison.

Ya I get what you are saying here, but thats if we are comparing it in the GCW era if we wanted the DS to have what we are saying they are having then it would be in the Legacy Era. At which point we are taking them being archaic by comparison to the Pellaeon which was the Imp duec of its time. It should be noted the Pellaeon I think is being underestimated here in terms of firepower.

"The class had slightly more armament than the older Imperial II-class Star Destroyer.[3] Some of these guns were of a similar design to the XX-9 turbolaser batteries of the old Galactic Empire.[7] The Pellaeon-class also possessed an interdiction field, capable of pulling ships out of hyperspace.[4]"

ent
Heavy turbolaser batteries (50)[3]
Medium turbolaser batteries (50)[3]
Ion cannon batteries (40)[3]
Tractor beam projectors (20)[1]
Proton torpedo launchers (50)[3]
200 proton torpedoes[1]
Dont forget the Ion cannons or the Proton Torps.

They also had defensive capabilities more like the Mon Cal ships of its time and while I believe a direct comparison would be able if the DS didnt have the MC80 with the MC80 we have to compare them to the Imp of their time and upgrade the Imp Deuces and the like to be more in line with the ships of the time.


Also would like to note that the GA at that time was similar to the rebellion when it came to ship use, just about anything they got their hands on was a ship they tried to use. They were once again converting standard transport ships into warships as best they can, but they were never a substitute for actual warships.

If the DS doesnt have the 1 MC80 then we can do a direct comparison with all ships because simply put, you are right while they are "archaic" its design that makes them archaic when comparison to the ships sitting right next to them. No upgrade no down grade direct to direct for easy comparison of all ships.

Honestly I would prefer to avoid the messy era stuff and just say no MC80 makes it easier to compare and I highly doubt the 1 MC80 really helps the DS any way considering the Era in which they got it.

Yeah OK, that seems reasonable.

Anyway if your interested here are the (updated) rough naval breakdowns.

2 Things 1 What is a Imperial Communication ship? and 2 Which fleet had Imp 1's I thought both fleets used Imp Dueces exclusively at the time.

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Pride_of_Tarlandia

That is what I assumed but after checking the facts it seems they mainly used ISDs and only had a few ISD-IIs.

Where did you find that info might I ask, I kind of want to know more on this myself, and how did you compare the weapons was it just assumed that its weapons were on par with the Imp 1 or the Imp 2?