Please upgrade your browser for the best possible experience.

Chrome Firefox Internet Explorer
×

BioWare, you're TORParse's only hope...

STAR WARS: The Old Republic > English > General Discussion
BioWare, you're TORParse's only hope...
First BioWare Post First BioWare Post

Aelrail's Avatar


Aelrail
07.17.2013 , 11:19 AM | #61
Quote: Originally Posted by Superman_AZ View Post

By my math, if 20k people download, and 10 others benefit from it, giving your hypothesis the benefit of the doubt, this would encompass 200k raiders, not 600k. But, mox nix. Someone else is making a parser and people will have another useful tool soon enough. But, in 10 days... TORparse is done.
LOL, you are not very good at math, heh?

Stop spreading misinformation. 600k is the number of visitors to the web page which is a web log parser, 20K is the number of users of the live parser.
Bounty Hunter Rakshak - Shield Tech - 55
Sith Warrior Jorxen - Carnage - 55
Imperial SoulTakers Guild - Jedi Covenant server (US East)
CE Owner

Superman_AZ's Avatar


Superman_AZ
07.17.2013 , 11:22 AM | #62
Quote: Originally Posted by curtkram View Post
there are different ways to play this game. it would not be right to say one way is better than another. someone who only wants to log in to buy stuff from the cartel market is an exception, since that is not playing a game at all; that is shopping.

if what you're doing is just a very basic sort of "hit stuff" and running through planets 3 or 5 levels ahead of the content and such, or pugging warzones and flashpoints without actually knowing what abilities your class has and what they do, that's fine. i don't think it's right for someone else to tell you that you aren't playing the game right. that's the right game for you, and all i would ask is try to communicate with your pug group the best you can.

sometimes the content can actually be fairly difficult if you aren't overleveled or overgeared. that aspect of the game appeals to other people, and that is just as acceptable. for these people, they want to get every bit of damage they can (or know how to mitigate damage, heal, ect.) so they know which attack can give you a proc, and what order to hit buttons is best, and things like that. for these people, it's important to have a tool that provides feedback on what their attacks are doing. i'm not elite, or even particularly good, but the game i enjoy is to challenge myself the best i can and having a tool that provides feedback is necessary for that. otherwise, i'm just guessing. the point is, pretty much all raiders use this tool, or mox, or something similar.

this thread isn't really here for people who don't like tools that provide feedback based on what attacks you do. this thread is for the people that do like these tools and are upset they are losing a valuable tool. your posts dismissing them and saying they are a small minority that doesn't matter is not helpful.

the guy that said he was developing a .net tool also said he was not able to release it to the public because he didn't have a storage option available. maybe that will be worked out, but suggesting the problem has been solved and done is not accurate.

I have not "dismissed" anyone's gameplay or style. Nor am I undervaluing their opinion. I simply gave my input regarding Bioware's "buyout" of this item, their management of it, and gave more realistic definition to someone who was distorting the numbers merely to substantiate their claim. I am all for speculation, but when you start putting words in the mouth of the Dev and then trying to pass it off as Gospel, my BS meter tends to go wonky and I call people out on it. Make your point, but don't manipulate facts and numbers to try and make others look foolish.
"Be yourself, no one can ever tell you you're doing it wrong." ~ James Leo Herlihy

curtkram's Avatar


curtkram
07.17.2013 , 11:34 AM | #63
i see. you're comments about the percentage of active players in swtor that use parsers was an unbiased and honest look at the data available to arrive at the truth, since you thought other people were skewing the numbers to present a false picture of the current state of things.

to get the accurate percentage of players using parses, you would need some honest numbers of active players. some throw-away number of everyone who created a f2p account or something like that wouldn't work. we know that would create an inaccurate picture of what is happening. where was your data set for how many people are actually playing swtor? let's not use marketing numbers we know have been fudged. let's use a number that reflects people who actually log in and spend time playing the game.

short of honest numbers on both sides of the equation, your made-up math is no better than anyone else's, right? i'm not putting words in your mouth, i just don't understand why you think your analysis is accurate. it could be. i accept that as a possibility. just for me, your numbers raise the BS flag.

Superman_AZ's Avatar


Superman_AZ
07.17.2013 , 11:45 AM | #64
Quote: Originally Posted by curtkram View Post
i see. you're comments about the percentage of active players in swtor that use parsers was an unbiased and honest look at the data available to arrive at the truth, since you thought other people were skewing the numbers to present a false picture of the current state of things.

to get the accurate percentage of players using parses, you would need some honest numbers of active players. some throw-away number of everyone who created a f2p account or something like that wouldn't work. we know that would create an inaccurate picture of what is happening. where was your data set for how many people are actually playing swtor? let's not use marketing numbers we know have been fudged. let's use a number that reflects people who actually log in and spend time playing the game.

short of honest numbers on both sides of the equation, your made-up math is no better than anyone else's, right? i'm not putting words in your mouth, i just don't understand why you think your analysis is accurate. it could be. i accept that as a possibility. just for me, your numbers raise the BS flag.

Seems like everything I've said since Friday has raised some kind of flag. So, let me throw out my assumptions as well and just stick to the facts according to the Dev:

FACT: TORParse is shutting down 7/27/2013 and (according to Eric in this thread) Bioware will not intervene

FACT: 600K+ visits to the page since it's launch (does not specify in the post these are unique visits)

FACT: 20K+ unique users of the service

Those are the facts according to the page showing the announcement of the shutdown. Later in this very thread, Andryah quoted another poster who is a .NET developer who has created the framework for a new parser and is now looking into hosting locations for a reasonable rate.

Just so we are clear: I never mocked anyone, didn't lose my cool, did not resort to any type of name calling, stuck with the facts and threw in my own interpretation of those facts, and never once looked down on or talked bad about raiders using this tool, or the new one being developed.

I understand I painted a target on myself after my troll bashing on Friday, but at some point, folks need to understand I am not trying to limit others or question their gameplay / opinions. I have issues with certain individuals, but I would like to think I have been cool, calm, and collected in this thread and trying to speak hypothetically within reason. I blame no one but me for my reputation, but just because I have a temper with trolls doesn't invalidate my opinion, particularly when presented the way I have in this thread.
"Be yourself, no one can ever tell you you're doing it wrong." ~ James Leo Herlihy

curtkram's Avatar


curtkram
07.17.2013 , 12:06 PM | #65
i'm not certain as to what the numbers from torparse actually represent.

you used a figure of 5 million unique accounts in 18 months for swtor. that number is even more suspect. i'm pretty certain it doesn't represent concurrent log-ins or active members the way i would define "active." that number is also not the best comparison because 18 months is not comparable to the 3 months the torparse in-game client has been available.

generally, i believe there are lies, damn lies, and statistics. that would apply equally to the numbers you were refuting as well as the numbers you were creating. the original post by Aelrail could have been just read for it's intent, which is that there are a lot of people who have used the site, and left at that. so, what i don't understand, and what prompted my reply, is why you would feel the need to question the validity of such a statement when you don't even use these tools? i think if this was a topic you were interested in, it would make more sense to me. as it is though, you don't seem to care either way whether the community has parsing tools, or what features said tools would include. in that light, i believe there is no point to trying to make it look like this is only of interest to a small fraction of the community, which is what i believe you were trying to do.

this should not be taken as an attack on you personally; it's just a response trying to understand why you're reading a forum thread you don't care about and why you're trying to create an argument that suggest people who use parser programs are such an insignificant portion of the community.

Mazikeen's Avatar


Mazikeen
07.17.2013 , 12:15 PM | #66
Quote: Originally Posted by Aelrail View Post
You should read the statistics for the project, I would not consider over 600,000 unique visits a small portion of the player base, or hardly anyone.

Love how people generalize based only on their narrow view, or ignorance of what other people do.
And I love how people read 'unique visits' as 'individual users' when, in fact, it's the number of different IP addresses logged. Given the fact most users have dynamic IP addresses, this can be anywhere from 600,000 people to 1 habitual visitor with an ISP that changed their IP address way too frequently.

The point is, the numbers are an illusion, just like when an MMO company says they have X users when, in reality, only Y users are actually regularly active (or they have X paid accounts but fail to state that Y number of them are users with multiple accounts).

600,000 is nothing in internet terms. Nothing. There are YouTube videos that get 1 million in 24 hours.
"Someone ever tries to kill you, you try to kill 'em right back!" - Malcolm Reynolds

Elfa's Avatar


Elfa
07.17.2013 , 12:26 PM | #67
Quote: Originally Posted by EricMusco View Post
As someone who got his start on a fan site himself many years ago, I really appreciate what you are trying to do! Unfortunately, "taking over" a fan site or offering top secret development support/time to a fan site is just not something we do.

Just like many of you, I personally think TORParse is a great tool and I will be sad to see it go. One thing I have learned though from being on a fan site, and from being here at BioWare, is that when one site goes down, usually there are others ready to take their place.

-eric
You don't have to take over the site, but you guys could take the thing itself and build it into the game.
I'd like to sit down with the guy responsible for having Busta Rhymes fight Michael Myers in HALLOWEEN RESURRECTION. Then, before he could speak, I would slap him so hard his face would explode and his dog would die." - Jim Law

DAMossimo's Avatar


DAMossimo
07.17.2013 , 12:30 PM | #68
Quote: Originally Posted by curtkram View Post
this should not be taken as an attack on you personally; it's just a response trying to understand why you're reading a forum thread you don't care about and why you're trying to create an argument that suggest people who use parser programs are such an insignificant portion of the community.
This indeed.

Protip: If it doesn't affect you, just move along.

Some people just crave attention (positive or negative) though.

FWIW, as a fan and user of Torparse, I don't think BW/EA should take it over either. It is a great tool for raiders, but hardcore raiders are admittedly but a portion of the population. I would rather be able to choose a 3rd party program to use instead of being locked into some knock-off conjured up by this game's developers.

Superman_AZ's Avatar


Superman_AZ
07.17.2013 , 01:04 PM | #69
Quote: Originally Posted by curtkram View Post
you used a figure of 5 million unique accounts in 18 months for swtor. that number is even more suspect.

Each account created for SWTOR is represented by hovering over the name/avatar on the left. If you look closely, you can see I am account # 3504227. This number appears as part of the URL in a small white box in the lower left corner. The lowest number I ever saw was 1661 and the highest was 5083412. This would indicate to me there have been 5M+ accounts (free or otherwise) created in SWTOR since launch. If I am wrong about that number and its representation, then I will gladly retract my remark about 5M swtor accounts.
"Be yourself, no one can ever tell you you're doing it wrong." ~ James Leo Herlihy

Superman_AZ's Avatar


Superman_AZ
07.17.2013 , 01:07 PM | #70
Quote: Originally Posted by curtkram View Post
so, what i don't understand, and what prompted my reply, is why you would feel the need to question the validity of such a statement when you don't even use these tools?

I took interest in this topic because I found the use of the tool itself fascinating. What I took issue with was the interpretation by Aelrail. This is the purpose of a forum, to discuss and debate the merits of the information disseminated.
"Be yourself, no one can ever tell you you're doing it wrong." ~ James Leo Herlihy