Please upgrade your browser for the best possible experience.

Chrome Firefox Internet Explorer
×

This game could learn from SWG


TrakonBazzaak's Avatar


TrakonBazzaak
09.04.2012 , 02:36 AM | #341
Quote: Originally Posted by MajikMyst View Post
Uh.. No.. We are not losing subs because of PVP.. We are losing subs because WOW changed the market and spoiled many people.. When this game launched it was expected to compete with an 8 year old WOW with 3 expansions.. Which is simply unfair.. An MMO is never finished, it is always changing.. Their are always bugs and their will always be bugs.. The biggest reason this game is having troubles is a lot of people simply had unrealistic expectations..

Look at GW2 now.. They having massive troubles.. Anything from rampet account hacking to lack of functionality.. Again, the same problem.. Nobody seems to remember what it is like to play a vanilla MMO..

There is nothing wrong with this game.. Can it improve?? Sure.. But there is nothing wrong with it.. Same is true for GW2..

People spend years of their lives working on these games and we the community don't even have the respect or compassion to work with them at making the game better.. Instead it is nothing but a bunch of 'I quit' posts, 'This game is horrible' posts, and more QQ and whine whine about whatever.. Which doesn't help new customers in the least.. I guess now we know why GW2 had their forums turned off..
Oh there is most definitely something wrong with it.

I resubbed for a month and got every single piece of gear I wanted (full campaign, BIS mods from bh gear and BIS armorings for my belt and bracers) and had nothing else left to do other than roll another alt in a dull lifeless world.

This is Star Wars lite for noobs.



Its hello kitty island adventures with lightsabers.

No meaningful world pvp, hell barely world pvp at all. Space combat is a joke. Who wants to roll 7 alts? Oops already done that, and main has all the gear I could ever want until TFB.

Lets face it Bioware dropped the ball here, and tbh SWG was more fun

Did SWG go free to play in under a year?

Didnt think so buddy.

. Say it sucks all you want and claim it was a niche game(lmao, it dominated EQ in its day when the entire market held less than 2 million players swg had over 300k)

The point is This game, if it can be called that even though its not fun, is a turd in comparison.

Swg was the first game with /dance

The swg team spawned patents that were used in the industry for years when they wrote the code for it.
http://www.google.com/patents?id=rNaOAAAAEBAJ
http://www.google.com/patents?id=otaOAAAAEBAJ
http://www.google.com/patents?id=o9aOAAAAEBAJ

Did bioware have anything like this to show for all of its work?

Oh thats right, Bioware didnt even write the code for their own engine, they bought the craptacular hero engine licence, and it cost them a whopping 75000 dollars to do so. http://www.heroengine.com/heroengine/licensing-options/.

Half of the VO touted in this game to be so ground breaking is in an alien language that is recycled over and over.


This game is pale even in comparison to any Bioware game released pre EA aquisition.

The game is too easy, the storylines are lackluster at best with not a single arch among all classes, and dont go saying that its impossible to make meaningful story archs in an mmo. This was pure greed to get the game out faster.

So continue on in your quest to try and deface the swg memory and cling to your sinking phailboat as long as you can.

Good luck ever seeing the 8 year mark before sunset.
It may be nobody wants to be heroes except when it doesn't count, when it isn't challenging, that people would rather fight "pretend evil" than the real thing, but I don't personally believe that. I still think people are better than that.
Raph Koster

TrakonBazzaak's Avatar


TrakonBazzaak
09.04.2012 , 02:39 AM | #342
Quote: Originally Posted by ImperialSun View Post
"The fact that SWG was so unpopular makes it something for Bioware to stay away from" - This is what you said...not a fact, it is simply your opinion which you try and focibly present as a fact. That does not make it a fact.

You claim anyone who does like SWG is a minority group. Where is your eveidence? Oh thats right you dont have any - again just promoting your personal opinion as fact.

The above is also a clear indication of your inferral that the game was universally disliked. Again, your own personal opinion. So no, you dont use facts to make a point at all......

What number do you have by the way? You said "Especially since those opposing SWG have the number to back up their views.. " What number...where is it? What is it? I see no source for it linked in your post???? OH yes, just ANOTHER opinion of yours presented as fact.....

I'll tell you one thing that is a fact....over 3,000 people a night log on to an SWG EMU server to play. I do not have 3,000 on my SWTOR server every night to play with. Those are BOTH facts

Oh and another fact, in a recent BW poll the number 1 requested feature was 3d space combat like JTLS......the number 1 request!!!! That seems to indicate those that do not like SWG are actually the minority....see how hideous facts can be?

Happy trails...

Driz
Hey buddy, it was 2999 on the server............
Until I logged in......

/fistbump
It may be nobody wants to be heroes except when it doesn't count, when it isn't challenging, that people would rather fight "pretend evil" than the real thing, but I don't personally believe that. I still think people are better than that.
Raph Koster

Liquidacid's Avatar


Liquidacid
09.04.2012 , 02:39 AM | #343
Quote: Originally Posted by MajikMyst View Post
Space combat in my view is a given.. I think that would be just awsome!!

Players houses, I am uneasy about.. I really don't want to see huge sections of space blocked in with player houses.. What about our ships?? Can that be our house?? Or perhaps instance the houses??
the ships pretty much ARE instanced housing... I'm sure BW could throw in some fluff modifications for them tho or maybe a minigame or something so people actually have a reason to go to other's ships

I don't really care about housing because in general it's not used all that much by most people even in games that have it...

now customizable guild ships on the other hand would be nice...
"bibo ergo sum" ( I drink, therefore I am)

Teamwork is essential; it gives the enemy other people to shoot at.

ImperialSun's Avatar


ImperialSun
09.04.2012 , 02:40 AM | #344
Quote: Originally Posted by MajikMyst View Post
Space combat in my view is a given.. I think that would be just awsome!!

Players houses, I am uneasy about.. I really don't want to see huge sections of space blocked in with player houses.. What about our ships?? Can that be our house?? Or perhaps instance the houses??
Player housing would need to be instanced as we do not have the free form terrain generation of a sandbox game. That would be fine imo however the ability to do somethig with that house, ala decorating would be essential. I just like somewhere to show off trophies and loot and such however some players will happily spend hours decorating a player house....it was a very much underestimated feature of another game that I will not mention.

Driz

Jamus_Divinus's Avatar


Jamus_Divinus
09.04.2012 , 02:40 AM | #345
Quote: Originally Posted by MajikMyst View Post
Space combat in my view is a given.. I think that would be just awsome!!

Players houses, I am uneasy about.. I really don't want to see huge sections of space blocked in with player houses.. What about our ships?? Can that be our house?? Or perhaps instance the houses??
Oh I agree. TOR's planets aren't large enough to accomodate Player Cities but instanced player housing (Drommund Kaas/Coruscant) would be doable imo.

Different style 'appartments' from student shack to penthouse

Rift has recently announced it's Player Housing update and it looks like something TOR could manage.
http://www.riftjunkies.com/2012/08/1...using-in-rift/
Star Wars Galaxies - Bria Server - April 2005- December 2011
1,000,000,000+ Mounts:262/270 Pets:225/241
Achievement points:44250 Ships mastered: 24/24

MajikMyst's Avatar


MajikMyst
09.04.2012 , 02:41 AM | #346
Quote: Originally Posted by ImperialSun View Post
"The fact that SWG was so unpopular makes it something for Bioware to stay away from" - This is what you said...not a fact, it is simply your opinion which you try and focibly present as a fact. That does not make it a fact.

The numbers do.. Sorry..

You claim anyone who does like SWG is a minority group. Where is your eveidence? Oh thats right you dont have any - again just promoting your personal opinion as fact.

You are a minority group.. Again the numbers don't lie.. You are gonna have to deal with it??

The above is also a clear indication of your inferral that the game was universally disliked. Again, your own personal opinion. So no, you dont use facts to make a point at all......

Sorry.. There you are simply incorrect.. I was stating statistical fact and mirroring a decision that Bioware made years ago.. Stop looking for things that aren't there.. Nobody said it..


What number do you have by the way? You said "Especially since those opposing SWG have the number to back up their views.. " What number...where is it? What is it? I see no source for it linked in your post???? OH yes, just ANOTHER opinion of yours presented as fact.....

SWG for close to the last 4 years it was active had 100k or less subscriptions.. Falling to 50k in mid 2009..

Click here

I'll tell you one thing that is a fact....over 3,000 people a night log on to an SWG EMU server to play. I do not have 3,000 on my SWTOR server every night to play with. Those are BOTH facts

And one server.. Seriously?? Isn't that a bit desperate?? Comparing SWG EMU to a single server on TOR.. If have to do that, then you have no point.. Sorry..

Oh and another fact, in a recent BW poll the number 1 requested feature was 3d space combat like JTLS......the number 1 request!!!! That seems to indicate those that do not like SWG are actually the minority....see how hideous facts can be?

Like I said... SWG didn't invent space combat sims.. I am guessing you aren't old enough to have played X-wing, Tie fighter, XVT, or XWA?? The desire for space combat has nothing to do with SWG.. Sorry.. But you can think what you want.. But please.. Don't kid yourself..


Driz
Responses in teal..
Who is the more foolish? The fool or the fool that follows him?

[.] Lost but never forgotten!! 12-01-2011 R.I.P.

TrakonBazzaak's Avatar


TrakonBazzaak
09.04.2012 , 02:45 AM | #347
Quote: Originally Posted by MajikMyst View Post
Responses in teal..
The numbers don't lie thats right.

In a global market not exceeding 2 million at swgs launch, it held 300k subscribers.


This game, however, has under 500k subscribers in a market that now has 100 million potential customers.

A grain of sand in an ocean of lawl.

And also these numbers dont lie, swtor ftp in under a year, while swg charged for all 8 of its years.
It may be nobody wants to be heroes except when it doesn't count, when it isn't challenging, that people would rather fight "pretend evil" than the real thing, but I don't personally believe that. I still think people are better than that.
Raph Koster

MajikMyst's Avatar


MajikMyst
09.04.2012 , 03:02 AM | #348
Quote: Originally Posted by TrakonBazzaak View Post
The numbers don't lie thats right.

In a global market not exceeding 2 million at swgs launch, it held 300k subscribers.


This game, however, has under 500k subscribers in a market that now has 100 million potential customers.

A grain of sand in an ocean of lawl.

And also these numbers dont lie, swtor ftp in under a year, while swg charged for all 8 of its years.
Unless you share your source.. Your numbers are fictional.. Simple as that..
Who is the more foolish? The fool or the fool that follows him?

[.] Lost but never forgotten!! 12-01-2011 R.I.P.

ImperialSun's Avatar


ImperialSun
09.04.2012 , 03:02 AM | #349
Quote: Originally Posted by TrakonBazzaak View Post
The numbers don't lie thats right.

In a global market not exceeding 2 million at swgs launch, it held 300k subscribers.


This game, however, has under 500k subscribers in a market that now has 100 million potential customers.

A grain of sand in an ocean of lawl.

And also these numbers dont lie, swtor ftp in under a year, while swg charged for all 8 of its years.
QFT...This is my point entirely.

TrakonBazzaak's Avatar


TrakonBazzaak
09.04.2012 , 03:05 AM | #350
Quote: Originally Posted by MajikMyst View Post
I use facts to make the point.. It just so happens that my opinions go along with the facts.. It is called being in the know for some people..

I have repeatedly asked that this discussion be about features and not SWG.. That request is ignored by people that want to make hyperbole comments like 'SWG is universally hated.' even though there isn't a single person that has said that..

That my points are hideous.. Is that even an arguement??

I have said it in this thread.. I would love 3D space combat.. Ala XWA.. I think it would be awsome.. But that bit was missed so someone else can get back to bashing everyone because they have a difference of opinion from theirs..

The difference is.. I don't put 3d space combat on the realm of SWG.. I played 'X-wing', 'Tie Fighter', 'X-wing Vs. Tie', all of which predate SWG.. X-wing Alliance being the most recent and the best in my opinion, but still predating SWG.. Did I mention Decent, Dencent2, Decent 3, and Decent freespace?? All of which was 3d flight combat.. And predated SWG.. Trust me.. SWG didn't invent 3D space combat..

But you don't see other people demanding to make the point that X-wing, or XWA, or any other game has something to contribute to SWTOR.. Just the SWG people..

Like I said.. Can we talk about the features??

Attempting to force SWG down someone's throat is a bad idea.. Especially since those opposing SWG have the number to back up their views.. I would perfer if no game was mentioned and we just talked about featuers.. After all, that is what it is all about.. Featuers.. Leave SWG out of it..

If you liked SWG.. Fine.. That is your opinion..
You want to talk about features, and then bring a game with almost no mentionable features into the argument.

Let me put all of this into perspective for you friend.
Im in my 30's I was playing online roleplaying games when the grandfathers of this genre were working for free moderating the text muds I played.

Ive seen the rise of every major release in the western market, and ive seen the fall where applicable. (everything other than wow and eve)
this game is lackluster at best. It launched with no features at all, other than a poorly executed raid, and about 15 flashpoints.

Here is what it offers in the way of entertaining me on a month to month basis thus earning my sub.

3 operations.
A few boring space maps ala star fox.
a few warzones that are pointless after the gear grind.
Sitting on the fleet watching people troll.
Rolling 7 alts.

You think were all spoiled by wow eh? That we should just wait here and pay while Bioware slowly makes the game pay to win, and releases barely any content for us to do.

This game is a vertical progression game, and the vertical progression takes a month at best, unless you cant find a guild, and at that point you are even more bored than I am.

What did swg offer for us to do?

It allowed us to swim an a seemingly endless universe of chaotic emergence. We were allowed to make our own story, and thus entertain ourselves in the world they created.

It was not static, it was not stale, and it certainly wasn't lifeless.

Every month I paid for it was money that sony earned.

I wouldnt give Bioware half of the credit I do sony in that regard and I hate sony.

For myself, my wife, and most of my guild, paying Bioware a monthly fee is literally equivalent to burning money, wasting it, it would be better spent giving it away to a homeless person.

I have never felt more ripped off in my life in reguards to a monthly gaming service.

Which is why the game will go Free To Play this year.

This game isnt a worthy successor to SWG, hell its not even a worthy successor to kotor.
It may be nobody wants to be heroes except when it doesn't count, when it isn't challenging, that people would rather fight "pretend evil" than the real thing, but I don't personally believe that. I still think people are better than that.
Raph Koster