Please upgrade your browser for the best possible experience.

Chrome Firefox Internet Explorer
×

Guild Wars 2 Beta Weekend. SWTOR or GW2, what do you prefer?

STAR WARS: The Old Republic > English > General Discussion
Guild Wars 2 Beta Weekend. SWTOR or GW2, what do you prefer?

nskeen's Avatar


nskeen
04.29.2012 , 09:59 PM | #421
Quote: Originally Posted by DJMayhem View Post
If I'm playing an MMO with Humans and Creatures, with Swords and Magic and Castles and Keeps, it's going to be WoW, not another "fantasy" knock-off with subpar graphics and voice acting. Especially when the consensus keep saying the only stand out thing about GW2 is the PVP.

World PVP is not the be all end all. Certainly not enough to make me quit what I'm playing, buy and start a new game.

The only reason SWTOR had a chance to contend with the giant was because of the source material and established fan base. Fantasy MMOs are all the same with one or two "niche" things that try to differentiate themselves from the pack. In the end, if you like that genre of MMO go back to WoW.

If you want something different from creatures and castles, stick with SWTOR.
So wait because your swords glow, your bows shoot beams of light, and magic is called the force, it's totally different from a fantasy MMO?

Ricktur's Avatar


Ricktur
04.29.2012 , 10:01 PM | #422
Quote: Originally Posted by Jalez View Post
The DAoC community uses "postcount.net" as their home forums, if you want current and former DAoC players opinions on GW2 Beta weekend, look at that forum. Some positive reviews, some negative, but all in all it was recieved well by all the DaoC players I know, which is alot-x

Its really ashame because SWtoR was probably the 1 game that...if it did have awesome Open World RvR and some decent 8vs8, the vast majority of DAoC'rs would perfer it over GW2, but BioWare has pushed us into GW2 by not having ANY World RvR at all.
but what if all this stuff comes in 2-3 months? seriously thats still before GW2 will launch. so if swtor got all of these options in the game in about 2 months, what will you say?

swtor will be an entirely different game by the time GW2 launches. im staying wil swtor so i can be on the cutting edge, what about you?
Sgt. Boos Macarrage - Republic Trooper/Vanguard - PVE Tank Spec
Prophecy of the Five - US East PVP
Republic Commandos: First Ones In, Last Ones Out. Never Quit. Never Fail.

CrunkShizzle's Avatar


CrunkShizzle
04.29.2012 , 10:01 PM | #423
Quote: Originally Posted by Darth_Floppinger View Post
Define world PvP. Or rather what makes you want to do world PvP.

The thing is the WvW maps are so big (and there´s 4 of em) that they might just offer what many PvP´ers look for when they want world PvP. By that I mean, being able to roam a wide area and not being restricted by an arena or small´ish PvP zone. + there are 3 sides to spice things up.

Ofc if the primary motivation is ganking, killing lowbies/questing people and the likes, then no, GW2 doesn´t feature that.
my idea of world pvp is what you see in mmos like Lineage 2

and no,its not always ganking lowbies

ChazDoit's Avatar


ChazDoit
04.29.2012 , 10:01 PM | #424
Quote: Originally Posted by kiddynomite View Post
GW2 is by far BY FAR better than swtor will ever be and its still in beta,
If you dont believe me, try the WvWvW pvp in...
Oh boy, here we go again, Its like these brainwashed drones just throw that word and expect people to be impressed

CrunkShizzle's Avatar


CrunkShizzle
04.29.2012 , 10:01 PM | #425
Quote:
swtor will be an entirely different game by the time GW2 launches. im staying wil swtor so i can be on the cutting edge, what about you?
ya,swtor will be a pve only game.cuz all the pvpers will be playing gw2

teambff's Avatar


teambff
04.29.2012 , 10:01 PM | #426
Quote: Originally Posted by DJMayhem View Post
/yawn.

Sounds like Wintergrasp to me. No wait, it sounds like the old days of Alterac Valley. No wait, sounds like the older days of Southshore.
so, basically nothing can be cool or fun, cuz everything's been done? why do you even continue living then.
srsly.
it's nothing like wintergrasp or alterac valley. actually.
kinda like southshore of old but a little more action packed.

anyway, i don't get why everyone is obsessed with "new"... there isn't going to be much "new" ever. most things have been done. untill virtual reality when we can actually go into the games and live t hem.

try and lighten up and have some fun.

there definitely wasn't any yawning going on from my chair.
JOSS WHEDON is god!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D7vS4z6ngQo
"the scoobygang legacy" on server mind trick, and in all other games, and things, and in life.

Guajolote's Avatar


Guajolote
04.29.2012 , 10:02 PM | #427
Quote: Originally Posted by DJMayhem View Post
If you want something different from creatures and castles, stick with SWTOR.
Nothing fantasy about the Force, and nothing creaturey about rakghouls or banthas or wampas or krayt dragons or....

Do Star Wars fans just not understand the difference between sci-fi and fantasy? If all it takes is space travel, then count WoW in since they have the Draenei. And flying mounts in WoW are closer to feeling like space travel than anything you can do in SWTOR.

It's like a cultish hive-mind around here with everyone somehow thinking this isn't a fantasy game.

Keymod's Avatar


Keymod
04.29.2012 , 10:02 PM | #428
I prefer sw:tor due to the art style and GW2 had a in game store where u could use real money on gems which bought xp boosts, money, clothes. I could see this being the downfall as people might get advantages just for having more money. But that's the risk of a non sub game.

metalgearyoda's Avatar


metalgearyoda
04.29.2012 , 10:03 PM | #429
Quote: Originally Posted by ChazDoit View Post
Oh boy, here we go again, Its like these brainwashed drones just throw that word and expect people to be impressed
Yeah. all these biodrones.

Wait,

I mean guildwardrones.

but srsly, gw2 is the biggest let down since starwars episode 1: phantom menace
Ganking leads to anger, anger leads to hate, hate leads to pvp.
The Swtor forum attracts trolls because the forums are more fun than raiding dragon soul.
Complaining is the new meta game.

Arzhanin's Avatar


Arzhanin
04.29.2012 , 10:04 PM | #430
Hey folks,

We're dropping in another reminder here that discussions and replies posted in the General Discussion forum need to relate in some way to Star Wars™: The Old Republic™ in order to be considered on-topic. Please note that off-topic threads are typically closed if they do not meet this criteria.

While we understand that comparing to other games is a natural topic of discussion, we'd appreciate it if you took the above into consideration as you continue the discussion. Thanks for your understanding.