Please upgrade your browser for the best possible experience.

Chrome Firefox Internet Explorer

Palpatine vs Dumbledore

Rayla_Felana's Avatar

01.18.2012 , 12:29 AM | #11
This is very circumstancial, Can a spell block lightning? can the force defend against Dumbledore's spells? Which version of Sidious? truly I don't know whom could win.

Natherillen's Avatar

01.18.2012 , 08:46 AM | #12
Sidious, in my opinion.

He can consume the essence of a whole planet, manipulate anyone and wrap the existence.

But it's like comparing apples to oranges. If we compare the limits of their power, it'll be probably the one can affect a larger scale.

In the other hand, a force user doesn't need a tool to use the force. A lightsaber is not used to use the force, it's a thing that can be useful against a force user and it can be put to a good use by a force user with their connection to the being.

We all know that there are many restrictions apply to everyone who are dealing with the usage of a spell. A Sith can break the chains that are holding them in both philosophy and in their own line of reality.

A Sith is both deceptive and fierce, they doesn't stop or doubt at any point. Vader, he is not a real Sith. He is a slave to the Sith.

But it's not really a good thing opposing two different lines of realities.
You ask “What is life?” That is the same as asking “What is a carrot?” A carrot is a carrot and we know nothing more.
Anton Chekhov

Cratic's Avatar

01.18.2012 , 09:01 AM | #13
Quote: Originally Posted by Rhyltran View Post
Dumbledore couldn't destroy planets.
Dumbledore DIDN'T destroy a planet, but there's no saying he wasn't saving that for when people really pissed him off. Maybe he would just sit in his office at night, his finger hovering over the proverbial red button, muttering under his breath "Come on, just give me a reason."