Please upgrade your browser for the best possible experience.

Chrome Firefox Internet Explorer
×

From a Goldman Analyst Perspective on SWTOR

STAR WARS: The Old Republic > English > General Discussion
From a Goldman Analyst Perspective on SWTOR

ChimaeraUK's Avatar


ChimaeraUK
01.05.2012 , 07:15 PM | #191
Quote: Originally Posted by Bodypull View Post
A bunch of response.

Those saying "a fake" are either delusional or cannot afford to live in Manhattan :-)

<blah blah blah>

Those of us the went to Harvard / Stern / Wharton / Columbia...
You have some pretty serious ego issues, you might even be making some valid points but the size of your head is getting in the way.

Mr_Crueak's Avatar


Mr_Crueak
01.05.2012 , 07:15 PM | #192
Quote: Originally Posted by Kurenar View Post
I've cancelled my sub as have many others, does that not count as bleeding?
no, not if you have the same ammount or more influx of new players to counter the ones that are leaving. Takes 2 peices of information to figure out if playerbase is bleeding or not. It could be, but we nor anyone else but bioware or EA knows for a fact, the rest of us can only guess and that is just that a guess nothing else. wasted space as far as i'm concerned

Daeborn's Avatar


Daeborn
01.05.2012 , 07:15 PM | #193
Quote: Originally Posted by Bodypull View Post
wow 17 pages.
Well it is a bait thread after all.

Mormack's Avatar


Mormack
01.05.2012 , 07:15 PM | #194
Quote: Originally Posted by Zmidponk View Post
Who? Using what figures? From where?



Check the WoW forums some time. Even when the subscription numbers were skyrocketing (instead of declining, like they have been doing), there were quite a number of whiny 'I QUIT' posts. Nothing can be inferred from that, other than that some people like to whine.

Not to mention this little gem right here that has been around for forever:


Quote:
What killed WoW?
rooftop camping
the removal of rooftop camping
the lack of honor
the implementation of honor
the lack of dishonor
the implementation of dishonor
the removal of dishonor
the removal of wall walking
rank rewards
decaying rank
the removal of rank decay
the removal of PVP titles
Ahn'Qiraj
Scourge Invasion
Zul'Gurub
the cost of mounts
the lack of information about TBC
all information released about TBC
playable Blood Elves
playable Draenei
Horde Paladins
Alliance Shaman
flying mounts
the timing of the release of TBC
the cost of flight, Jewelcrafting
the LFG channel
holding people accountable to the Terms of Use
meeting stones
arenas
the number of arena teams one player can have
arena-based gear rewards
the lack of battlegrounds
the addition of battlegrounds
everything about battlegrounds
Illidan being killable
Daily quests
instance-based reputations
the Darkmoon Faire
/pizza
playable wisps
Tinfoil Hat
the Armory
Warden
the lack of information about Wrath
all information about Wrath
a failure to revamp old world areas
the inability to transfer from PVE to PVP servers
hero classes
siege engines
cold weather flying
Wintergrasp being a PVP zone
death knights
the inability to start a new character of any class at 55 or higher
the lack of a dance studio
character recustomization
the inability to change race or faction
the cost of mammoths and motorcycles
Spirit of Competition
the fall damage negation of mammoths and motorcycles
the removal of fall damage negation from mammoths and motorcycles
the ability to transfer from PVE to PVP servers
dual specs
Achievements
holiday events
Mountain Dew Game Fuel
streaming Blizzcon ’09 on pay per view
the revamping of Onyxia’s Lair
Worgen for the Alliance
Goblins for the Horde
revamped old world areas
the ability to change faction
the ability to change race
new race/class combinations
purchasable vanity pets
Icecrown Citadel
cross realm LFG
Celestial Steeds
the Disenchant option added to Need/Greed
combining raid lockouts
the initial announcement, then delay, then lack of information, then announcement, of the new X-53 Touring Rocket RAF reward mount
the removal of Path of the Titans
Archaeology
changes to Archaeology
the introduction of RealID as an option to the game servers
the introduction of RealID as a matter of mandatory disclosure for forum participation
as well as weekly maintenance and patches 1.1 through the current one inclusive.

Abriael's Avatar


Abriael
01.05.2012 , 07:16 PM | #195
Quote: Originally Posted by Kurenar View Post
Man fanboy you're getting rage foam on my jacket! No one but BW can provide absolute proof of any numbers right now, should that stop all logical speculation? I've cancelled my sub as have many others, does that not count as bleeding?
And for anyone with no shred of logic (because it takes lacking any kind of logic to cancel a mmo subscription before the free priod even runs out) that drops, there are others that join.. So no, no "beeding" can be proved at the moment.

Malphas's Avatar


Malphas
01.05.2012 , 07:16 PM | #196
Well, he also said swtor had 4-5 million subs. I'm pretty sure if there were ever that many Bioware would have announced it.

onanonehand's Avatar


onanonehand
01.05.2012 , 07:16 PM | #197
Bioware is a company (captain obvious...I know). They did the research. They developed a product. Now they are building a customer base. They will succeed or they won't.

They did more research than the goldman guy. Yeah chest puffery is in vogue. I don't know if Bioware/EA will succeed and neither does the goldman guy. I will say this, if my financial advisor was suggesting I invest in a video game I would be looking for a new advisor.

If any of the posters here think their input will make or break this game, they need to be medicated.

Mackuss's Avatar


Mackuss
01.05.2012 , 07:16 PM | #198
Extremely well written, OP, and I agree with absolutely everything.

I suspect a lot of peolpe are "disagreeing" with you, but because they are incapable of understanding what you are saying, and why you are saying it.
while(horse.State == dead)
{
horse.beat();
}

SnoggyMack's Avatar


SnoggyMack
01.05.2012 , 07:16 PM | #199
Quote: Originally Posted by Bodypull View Post
Star Wars has a large following, however ...

How many Star Wars fans play MMO's?

MMO's appeal to the same "audience" that comic books, video games, and other pop culture appeal to.

How many Star Wars fans play World of Warcraft? A lot.

Quote:
Star Trek online failed because they banked on Brand Recognition and the mislead confidence that Star Trek fans play MMO's, most do not. (or simp;y those that do, opted for a better game.)
Star Trek Online failed because:

1- Perpetual took money and wasted years of development time.
2- Cryptic Studios built the game on the engine that was initially designed for a super hero MMORPG (which was first for Marvel but then became Champions). They then were given 18 months to pump out the game.
3- They released it with one and a half factions and a terrible exploration system.
4- They then spent the next two years not developing the game's content properly. Case in point, they went the entirety of 2010 releasing only ONE featured episode arc.
5- Speaking of 2010, Atari ... wow what a mess.

The game failed because of poor development. Don't believe me? You ALL can play it for free on January 17.


You continually demonstrate a complete lack of experience with the genre that you claim to give analysis and advice about. Your expertise is lacking. You should probably be giving more investment advice on cars, as your car analogy (a classic and extremely weak internet talking point) was stronger and deeper than anything you've posted about MMORPGs.
Snoggy Mack
My Blog
My quote: "All the other kids with the pumped up Sith, you better run, better run, faster than my blaster"

TheHeadCapper's Avatar


TheHeadCapper
01.05.2012 , 07:16 PM | #200
Quote: Originally Posted by Xugos View Post
Evidently, the OP's well-reasoned and logical post has made many a fanboy's cranium implode.
The basics of data analysis/analytics, which he doesn't follow.

Nothing to do with liking or disliking the game, but you guys are clueless. I'm offended as an analyst not as an SWTOR player

•Data collection
•Data collation
•Summary measures of the data
•Conclusions based on the above


Data collection - no it's a gut feeling
Data collation - he doesn't have any data
Summary of data - no he doesn't hav any data
Conclusion based on data - impossible he doesn't have any data
The formula 'two plus two equals five' is not without its attractions