I can't make my damn mind up! Here's the thing:

 

With the forthcoming revert of Watchman discipline, I have become very uncertain of my JKs AC. Here are things I like about Guardian:

 

-> Guardian's Renowned set(no longer applicable, Sents can equip it in O.Designer)

-> Single Saber style(just so iconic, plus I prefer single 1H weapon style no matter what)

-> Forms. I am such a big fan of all the three forms from Guardian. Shien especially with its counterattack focus.

-> Tanky DPS feel(kinda not applicable because Sents are helluva tough when played right as well)

-> Ability to tank.

 

Dislike:

 

-> Focus on strength. I just dislike brute power.

-> Boring compared to Sentinel

 

Here's about Sent:

 

Like:

 

-> Focus on dexterity. This suits me more than RAAAAAWR of Guardian.

-> FUN. The class is so, so fun. It's touched by the universe damn it.

-> Tanky DPS feel

-> Very elaborate gameplay. Zen etc

 

Dislike:

 

-> Two lightsabres. Well, not exactly, but 1 is better imo.

-> No favourite forms/too agressive forms.

 

I just...can't! It's impossible! HALP!

Normally I would say Guardian since it's better for many reasons. But since it seems you happen to find Sentinel fun, you should go with Sentinel. Don't let the meta ruin your fun.

I mean I do have Marauder, but RP wise it's just not the same. One is a Watchman and the other is a Hunter. In mechanic terms: one is about DoT while the other is about Direct dmg.

 

I'll have to think(and suffer ) some more.