Am curious to what you all think would've happened if Anakin did not stop Mace Windu as he was about to strike the Emperor. Please be logical in your responses ;P What do you think would've happened to Anakin? Padme? The entire story? The legacy of Vader, Luke, Leiah... everything! XD Discuss away lore lovers.

I guess more thorough than logical, lol. But both are good.

Boss Nass would have thrown Sidious out the window and assumed the role of Sith Lord. Mace Windu and Anakin would be so awestricken and dumbfounded that they would have knelt at his feet right then and there. Then Boss Nass would have had 2 Sith Apprentices, Darth Vader and Darth Bad MotherF***er. Edited April 1, 2012 by Datamonger

Sidious was prepared for that, he pretended to lost to corrupt Anakin.

Sidious was prepared for that, he pretended to lost to corrupt Anakin.

 

I understand that... what I'm asking though, is what if Anakin did NOT stop Windu, and Sidious died there. I'm asking for what you guys think would happen story wise, re-read the original post, please XP

I understand that... what I'm asking though, is what if Anakin did NOT stop Windu, and Sidious died there. I'm asking for what you guys think would happen story wise, re-read the original post, please XP

 

Sidious wouldn't have died, heres my take on how it would go and the after effects if Anakin never arrived in the office.

---

 

Anakin never arrives at Palpatine's office, thus he kills Mace Windu with his superiority in the force. He then realizes that getting Anakin to be his apprentice is now impossible, and then executes Order 66 with jedi around the galaxy dying. The raid on the temple is led by a detactment of Palpatine's royal guard leading the 501st, though because of Anakin not leading the attack is considered somewhat of a failure. Only 3 survivors in the temple are left, and they are Anakin Skywalker, Cin Drallig and Shaak Ti the 3 leave the temple and link up with Bail Organa, Yoda and Obi-Wan.

 

Padme gives birth to Luke and Leia, and the jedi go into hiding as the Galactic Empire takes control of the galaxy and the jedi are considered traitors. A few years pass, Luke and Leia begin their jedi training while the Rebel Alliance fights against the Empire though they have more resources and ships to start with being that they had help from the jedi raiding several Imperial convoys and getting many planets to support them. At this point Palpatine has a new apprentice, named Darth Anubis who is a very powerful sith lord. The battle of Yavin is roughly the same, and they leave Yavin IV in search of a new base of operations.

 

Eventually they set up on Hoth, and the battle of hoth does take place however since the Rebel Alliance has more resources, they have heavy artillery and their snowspeeders to combat the AT-ATs. Blizzard force led by General Veers, is taking heavy loses but not before the shield generator is destroyed and Darth Anbuis lands. Only Anakin and Cin are in the base, Shaak Ti, Obi-Wan, Yoda, Padme, Luke, Han and Chewie are out in the galaxy doing other Rebel operations on other worlds. Darth Anbuis enters the hanger where Anakin and Cin engage the sith lord in a fierce duel, Cin attacking first before being kicked back.

 

Anubis then uses force lighting against Anakin but he blocks it with his saber, Cin comes back using force speed and drives back the sith lord with Anakin before they disarmed him. The battle of hoth is in the Rebellion's favor, and Anubis is taken into custody where Alliance High Command executes him shortly after. A few more years pass, Yoda dies and Luke and Anakin have reached their full potential becoming the most powerful force users in history. Palpatine senses the demise of his apprentice, and he knows that he will soon be next meanwhile the Rebels are preparing their attack on the 2nd death star.

 

It all pretty much goes the same like in the movie, its a trap and such however the strike team consists of Han, Cin, Chewie and Luke with a detachment of Rebel Specforce Wilderness Fighters. They defeat the legion of stormtroopers with the ewoks help, and blow the shield bunker using charges while Leia, Shaak Ti, and Obi-Wan are coordinating the fleet attack(the fleet being 5X larger then what it was in the movies). Anakin meanwhile lands aboard the 2nd death star, while the battle goes on and heads towards the throne room confronting Palpatine. In a fierce duel, Anakin soon overcomes Palpatine and kills him before escaping the death star as it is about to blow.

 

With the 2nd death star destroyed, the Rebel fleet engages the remaining and demoralized imperial fleet forcing them to retreat into hyperspace. The war continues on for another few more years, and then The New Republic is formed.

Sidious will shock the lightning back and kill Windu when he could not hold anymore. In the novel Windu already used all his strength before Sidious said"NO NO I'm too weak".

 

The real chance to kill Sidious was that when GG ordered the destruction of the Invisible Hand, too bad Anakin was able to make a safe landing.

Edited April 1, 2012 by Slowpokeking

Anakin still would have gone Dark. Nothing was stopping that. Sideous was a father figure to him and watching him being struck down would have fueled his hate further. I think he would have continued his dark training somehow. Even if it was in the way that Sideous shrouded the dark side to keep hidden from the Jedi. Anakin was corrupt in AOTC when he decided to give into his anger and strike down all of those Tuskens. He also already had dislike for Obi during those times as he felt he was being held back. Again, feelings of which all lead to hate.

 

The only thing that would have changed, was who the puppet master was during the original trilogy, Story line.

Sidious wouldn't have died, heres my take on how it would go and the after effects if Anakin never arrived in the office.

---

 

Anakin never arrives at Palpatine's office, thus he kills Mace Windu with his superiority in the force. He then realizes that getting Anakin to be his apprentice is now impossible, and then executes Order 66 with jedi around the galaxy dying. The raid on the temple is led by a detactment of Palpatine's royal guard leading the 501st, though because of Anakin not leading the attack is considered somewhat of a failure. Only 3 survivors in the temple are left, and they are Anakin Skywalker, Cin Drallig and Shaak Ti the 3 leave the temple and link up with Bail Organa, Yoda and Obi-Wan.

 

Padme gives birth to Luke and Leia, and the jedi go into hiding as the Galactic Empire takes control of the galaxy and the jedi are considered traitors. A few years pass, Luke and Leia begin their jedi training while the Rebel Alliance fights against the Empire though they have more resources and ships to start with being that they had help from the jedi raiding several Imperial convoys and getting many planets to support them. At this point Palpatine has a new apprentice, named Darth Anubis who is a very powerful sith lord. The battle of Yavin is roughly the same, and they leave Yavin IV in search of a new base of operations.

 

Eventually they set up on Hoth, and the battle of hoth does take place however since the Rebel Alliance has more resources, they have heavy artillery and their snowspeeders to combat the AT-ATs. Blizzard force led by General Veers, is taking heavy loses but not before the shield generator is destroyed and Darth Anbuis lands. Only Anakin and Cin are in the base, Shaak Ti, Obi-Wan, Yoda, Padme, Luke, Han and Chewie are out in the galaxy doing other Rebel operations on other worlds. Darth Anbuis enters the hanger where Anakin and Cin engage the sith lord in a fierce duel, Cin attacking first before being kicked back.

 

Anubis then uses force lighting against Anakin but he blocks it with his saber, Cin comes back using force speed and drives back the sith lord with Anakin before they disarmed him. The battle of hoth is in the Rebellion's favor, and Anubis is taken into custody where Alliance High Command executes him shortly after. A few more years pass, Yoda dies and Luke and Anakin have reached their full potential becoming the most powerful force users in history. Palpatine senses the demise of his apprentice, and he knows that he will soon be next meanwhile the Rebels are preparing their attack on the 2nd death star.

 

It all pretty much goes the same like in the movie, its a trap and such however the strike team consists of Han, Cin, Chewie and Luke with a detachment of Rebel Specforce Wilderness Fighters. They defeat the legion of stormtroopers with the ewoks help, and blow the shield bunker using charges while Leia, Shaak Ti, and Obi-Wan are coordinating the fleet attack(the fleet being 5X larger then what it was in the movies). Anakin meanwhile lands aboard the 2nd death star, while the battle goes on and heads towards the throne room confronting Palpatine. In a fierce duel, Anakin soon overcomes Palpatine and kills him before escaping the death star as it is about to blow.

 

With the 2nd death star destroyed, the Rebel fleet engages the remaining and demoralized imperial fleet forcing them to retreat into hyperspace. The war continues on for another few more years, and then The New Republic is formed.

 

This is awesome! Well done... you should think of turning this into a novel XD

Anakin still would have gone Dark. Nothing was stopping that. Sideous was a father figure to him and watching him being struck down would have fueled his hate further. I think he would have continued his dark training somehow. Even if it was in the way that Sideous shrouded the dark side to keep hidden from the Jedi. Anakin was corrupt in AOTC when he decided to give into his anger and strike down all of those Tuskens. He also already had dislike for Obi during those times as he felt he was being held back. Again, feelings of which all lead to hate.

 

The only thing that would have changed, was who the puppet master was during the original trilogy, Story line.

 

I think many people will do the same to those Tuskens if they were on Anakin's position.

This is awesome! Well done... you should think of turning this into a novel XD

 

Eh, I ain't no great writer to make a novel. I have a creative mind with certain things, but its hard for me to actual put it down on paper.

Edited April 1, 2012 by Wolfninjajedi

Eh, I ain't no great writer to make a novel. I have a creative mind with certain things, but its hard for me to actual put it down on paper.

 

Even so, Lucas would be proud. It's a great lay-out!

honestly? windu loses to sidious in a long drawn out and epic fight, though windu fairs better then yoda sheerly because he isn't as arrogant as yoda and doesnt let idea he's jedi warp his perception of fight. This was probably biggest reason yoda lost he underestimated sidious where as from what we saw of windu he didnt and he was much more serious in his battles. I feel yoda was stronger in the force, maybe he was even better with his saber BUT windu just has a much better fighting mentality and he's a no none sense kind of warrior. plus his saber combat style is much more aggressive and probably throw sidious off his game.

honestly? windu loses to sidious in a long drawn out and epic fight, though windu fairs better then yoda sheerly because he isn't as arrogant as yoda and doesnt let idea he's jedi warp his perception of fight. This was probably biggest reason yoda lost he underestimated sidious where as from what we saw of windu he didnt and he was much more serious in his battles. I feel yoda was stronger in the force, maybe he was even better with his saber BUT windu just has a much better fighting mentality and he's a no none sense kind of warrior. plus his saber combat style is much more aggressive and probably throw sidious off his game.

 

Windu could take on Sidious for so long mainly because his Vaapad style could reflect Dark Side of the Force.

Windu could take on Sidious for so long mainly because his Vaapad style could reflect Dark Side of the Force.

 

I'm thinking if Windu had used any other form, he would have been floored quickly or at the very least not last as long as he did and come out as the winner.

Edited April 1, 2012 by Wolfninjajedi

I think Palpatine's form also mattered, from the description in the novel it's like he's using Juyo, so it's more like a force battle rather than sword duel.

If Anakin had not being coming to his rescue Sidious would have never stopped the Lightning barge are just kept on until Windu was overwhelmed, then fried him.

 

Windu may have legitimately won the Lightsaber portion of the fight, but Windu was on losing end of that Lightning vs Saberblock exchange, as few more seconds and toast. But then Anakin came in so Sidious went for he double win, dead Windu and corrupted Anakin.

Edited April 1, 2012 by AngelousWang

Sidious wouldn't have died, heres my take on how it would go and the after effects if Anakin never arrived in the office.

---

 

Anakin never arrives at Palpatine's office, thus he kills Mace Windu with his superiority in the force. He then realizes that getting Anakin to be his apprentice is now impossible, and then executes Order 66 with jedi around the galaxy dying. The raid on the temple is led by a detactment of Palpatine's royal guard leading the 501st, though because of Anakin not leading the attack is considered somewhat of a failure. Only 3 survivors in the temple are left, and they are Anakin Skywalker, Cin Drallig and Shaak Ti the 3 leave the temple and link up with Bail Organa, Yoda and Obi-Wan.

 

Padme gives birth to Luke and Leia, and the jedi go into hiding as the Galactic Empire takes control of the galaxy and the jedi are considered traitors. A few years pass, Luke and Leia begin their jedi training while the Rebel Alliance fights against the Empire though they have more resources and ships to start with being that they had help from the jedi raiding several Imperial convoys and getting many planets to support them. At this point Palpatine has a new apprentice, named Darth Anubis who is a very powerful sith lord. The battle of Yavin is roughly the same, and they leave Yavin IV in search of a new base of operations.

 

Eventually they set up on Hoth, and the battle of hoth does take place however since the Rebel Alliance has more resources, they have heavy artillery and their snowspeeders to combat the AT-ATs. Blizzard force led by General Veers, is taking heavy loses but not before the shield generator is destroyed and Darth Anbuis lands. Only Anakin and Cin are in the base, Shaak Ti, Obi-Wan, Yoda, Padme, Luke, Han and Chewie are out in the galaxy doing other Rebel operations on other worlds. Darth Anbuis enters the hanger where Anakin and Cin engage the sith lord in a fierce duel, Cin attacking first before being kicked back.

 

Anubis then uses force lighting against Anakin but he blocks it with his saber, Cin comes back using force speed and drives back the sith lord with Anakin before they disarmed him. The battle of hoth is in the Rebellion's favor, and Anubis is taken into custody where Alliance High Command executes him shortly after. A few more years pass, Yoda dies and Luke and Anakin have reached their full potential becoming the most powerful force users in history. Palpatine senses the demise of his apprentice, and he knows that he will soon be next meanwhile the Rebels are preparing their attack on the 2nd death star.

 

It all pretty much goes the same like in the movie, its a trap and such however the strike team consists of Han, Cin, Chewie and Luke with a detachment of Rebel Specforce Wilderness Fighters. They defeat the legion of stormtroopers with the ewoks help, and blow the shield bunker using charges while Leia, Shaak Ti, and Obi-Wan are coordinating the fleet attack(the fleet being 5X larger then what it was in the movies). Anakin meanwhile lands aboard the 2nd death star, while the battle goes on and heads towards the throne room confronting Palpatine. In a fierce duel, Anakin soon overcomes Palpatine and kills him before escaping the death star as it is about to blow.

 

With the 2nd death star destroyed, the Rebel fleet engages the remaining and demoralized imperial fleet forcing them to retreat into hyperspace. The war continues on for another few more years, and then The New Republic is formed.

 

You forgot that Imperial Gunnery Officer that decided NOT to fire on the escape pod because he had to budget laser expendatures. Without him making that decision, everything else would have fallen apart.

Sidious wouldn't have died, heres my take on how it would go and the after effects if Anakin never arrived in the office.

---

 

Anakin never arrives at Palpatine's office, thus he kills Mace Windu with his superiority in the force. He then realizes that getting Anakin to be his apprentice is now impossible, and then executes Order 66 with jedi around the galaxy dying. The raid on the temple is led by a detactment of Palpatine's royal guard leading the 501st, though because of Anakin not leading the attack is considered somewhat of a failure. Only 3 survivors in the temple are left, and they are Anakin Skywalker, Cin Drallig and Shaak Ti the 3 leave the temple and link up with Bail Organa, Yoda and Obi-Wan.

 

Padme gives birth to Luke and Leia, and the jedi go into hiding as the Galactic Empire takes control of the galaxy and the jedi are considered traitors. A few years pass, Luke and Leia begin their jedi training while the Rebel Alliance fights against the Empire though they have more resources and ships to start with being that they had help from the jedi raiding several Imperial convoys and getting many planets to support them. At this point Palpatine has a new apprentice, named Darth Anubis who is a very powerful sith lord. The battle of Yavin is roughly the same, and they leave Yavin IV in search of a new base of operations.

 

Eventually they set up on Hoth, and the battle of hoth does take place however since the Rebel Alliance has more resources, they have heavy artillery and their snowspeeders to combat the AT-ATs. Blizzard force led by General Veers, is taking heavy loses but not before the shield generator is destroyed and Darth Anbuis lands. Only Anakin and Cin are in the base, Shaak Ti, Obi-Wan, Yoda, Padme, Luke, Han and Chewie are out in the galaxy doing other Rebel operations on other worlds. Darth Anbuis enters the hanger where Anakin and Cin engage the sith lord in a fierce duel, Cin attacking first before being kicked back.

 

Anubis then uses force lighting against Anakin but he blocks it with his saber, Cin comes back using force speed and drives back the sith lord with Anakin before they disarmed him. The battle of hoth is in the Rebellion's favor, and Anubis is taken into custody where Alliance High Command executes him shortly after. A few more years pass, Yoda dies and Luke and Anakin have reached their full potential becoming the most powerful force users in history. Palpatine senses the demise of his apprentice, and he knows that he will soon be next meanwhile the Rebels are preparing their attack on the 2nd death star.

 

It all pretty much goes the same like in the movie, its a trap and such however the strike team consists of Han, Cin, Chewie and Luke with a detachment of Rebel Specforce Wilderness Fighters. They defeat the legion of stormtroopers with the ewoks help, and blow the shield bunker using charges while Leia, Shaak Ti, and Obi-Wan are coordinating the fleet attack(the fleet being 5X larger then what it was in the movies). Anakin meanwhile lands aboard the 2nd death star, while the battle goes on and heads towards the throne room confronting Palpatine. In a fierce duel, Anakin soon overcomes Palpatine and kills him before escaping the death star as it is about to blow.

 

With the 2nd death star destroyed, the Rebel fleet engages the remaining and demoralized imperial fleet forcing them to retreat into hyperspace. The war continues on for another few more years, and then The New Republic is formed.

 

This post is the most amazing thing ever created. How did you come up with Darth Anubis and stuff?

This post is the most amazing thing ever created. How did you come up with Darth Anubis and stuff?

 

Eh it just came to me really, popped right into my head.

 

And Captain I know, but the post was really just a rough idea. There would be more details to it, if I actually wanted to make a story out of it.

Edited April 1, 2012 by Wolfninjajedi

Boss Nass would have thrown Sidious out the window and assumed the role of Sith Lord. Mace Windu and Anakin would be so awestricken and dumbfounded that they would have knelt at his feet right then and there. Then Boss Nass would have had 2 Sith Apprentices, Darth Vader and Darth Bad MotherF***er.

 

This.

Eh, I ain't no great writer to make a novel. I have a creative mind with certain things, but its hard for me to actual put it down on paper.

 

Do it anyway. Have confidence in your self. Your story is interesting and you already have a format and direction which is much more than most start out with.

 

Just write it let that creative mind do its thing.

Do it anyway. Have confidence in your self. Your story is interesting and you already have a format and direction which is much more than most start out with.

 

Just write it let that creative mind do its thing.

 

You guys really want me to write it? Lol.

If Anakin had not being coming to his rescue Sidious would have never stopped the Lightning barge are just kept on until Windu was overwhelmed, then fried him.

 

Windu may have legitimately won the Lightsaber portion of the fight, but Windu was on losing end of that Lightning vs Saberblock exchange, as few more seconds and toast. But then Anakin came in so Sidious went for he double win, dead Windu and corrupted Anakin.

 

My own thoughts on the matter.

 

It would be nice to think Windu actually did stand a chance, unfortunately, the plot armor was strong with Sidious.

My own thoughts on the matter.

 

It would be nice to think Windu actually did stand a chance, unfortunately, the plot armor was strong with Sidious.

 

Ok, let's take Plot Armor out of the equation.

 

Windu beats the **** out of both them mutha****as and wins.