Saw this on Bluesnews http://www.mackandmesh.co.uk/reviews/star-wars-the-old-republic.php it's the most accurate review I have seen.

be back in 45 mins..

 

Jesus, did this guy go over every blade of grass or something?

Saw this on Bluesnews http://www.mackandmesh.co.uk/reviews/star-wars-the-old-republic.php it's the most accurate review I have seen.

 

Sorry, not gonna watch a 45 minute video review, just cause someone says it's most accurate (which would be a matter of opinion anyway).

Sorry, not gonna watch a 45 minute video review, just cause someone says it's most accurate (which would be a matter of opinion anyway).

 

And you felt the need to say this...why?

Saw this on Bluesnews http://www.mackandmesh.co.uk/reviews/star-wars-the-old-republic.php it's the most accurate review I have seen.

 

Accurate to you personally perhaps. People need to understand that there is no "real" or "fake" reviews as long as the reviewer is being honest in their opinion. Different people can see the same thing in many different ways. This review is no "better " than any other honest review, its just one guys opinion.

Eh. I disagree with their review. SWTOR is a good game. It might not be the game for you, but it's a good game.

Reviews mean nothing, TOR got 4/5 from gamespy WAR got 5/5 both games suck on the same level tho

Well, it's not a rewiev. But a neat video, still.

How is this one more or less realistic than any of the ones out there already?

Translation: I found a review I agree with therefore it's realistic and accurate.

 

 

I don't care for reviews, good or bad. I form my own opinion by playing.

First off..how are any of you done watching it already? Unless you've already seen it?

 

Secondly if you watched it and I'm only 6 mins in, you would know that it's less like a review and more like a first impression.

 

Much like TotalBiscuit does, if you're familiar with him?

 

And you have to understand that the game being in beta for so long and to come out the way it is is just pathetic..idc if you're having fun or not you have to know that things are broken and missing. And for being an MMO in 2012, new or not that's unacceptable.

Edited January 15, 2012 by Slomoshun

its just one guys opinion.

 

Well technically it was the opinion of two guys... I lost interest pretty quickly. Then again I've already played the game and formed my own opinion.

And you felt the need to say this...why?

 

Because, I want to give other people a chance to know that it's a 45 minute video review, which I felt annoyed at finding out because he didn't mention it.

 

I wouldn't even have clicked the link if I'd know that. Now people have a fair chance.

 

Are you the OP's best friend or what? You're mighty defensive about this.

Because, I want to give other people a chance to know that it's a 45 minute video review, which I felt annoyed at finding out because he didn't mention it.

 

I wouldn't even have clicked the link if I'd know that. Now people have a fair chance.

 

Are you the OP's best friend or what? You're mighty defensive about this.

 

thanks for white knighting this review for everyone

First off..how are any of you done watching it already? Unless you've already seen it?

 

Secondly if you watched it and I'm only 6 mins in, you would know that it's less like a review and more like a first impression.

 

Much like TotalBiscuit does, if you're familiar with him?

 

And you have to understand that the game being in beta for so long and to come out the way it is is just pathetic..idc if you're having fun or not you have to know that things are broken and missing. And for being an MMO in 2012, new or not that's unacceptable.

 

No one is bothering to watch it, because:

 

1) It's 45 minutes long. I have better things to do than care about someone else's opinion.

 

2) You call the review "realistic," which is nonsense. Reviews are opinions, not facts.

 

3) You dug up one review that you agree with and posted it, which is the equivalent of a "this is my opinion of the game" thread. Dead horse.

thanks for white knighting this review for everyone

 

I believe in fair warning on the forum

No one is bothering to watch it, because:

 

1) It's 45 minutes long. I have better things to do than care about someone else's opinion.

 

2) You call the review "realistic," which is nonsense. Reviews are opinions, not facts.

 

3) You dug up one review that you agree with and posted it, which is the equivalent of a "this is my opinion of the game" thread. Dead horse.

 

You really need to get your facts straight before you quote someone, bud.

 

1. It is 45 mins long and you're on the forums which suggests you have NOTHING to do at this time.

 

2. I didn't call it a review the OP did, but 3 minutes in I could tell that it's not a review it's a first impression..there is a difference, educate yourself please.

 

3. I'm not the OP so why are you even saying this?

Translation: I found a review I agree with therefore it's realistic and accurate.

 

 

I don't care for reviews, good or bad. I form my own opinion by playing.

 

This is about the truest statement i've seen on these forums.

Saw this on Bluesnews http://www.mackandmesh.co.uk/reviews/star-wars-the-old-republic.php it's the most accurate review I have seen.

I do not mean any direct offence to you, Gankdalf, but when people describe a review as the most accurate/best/insightful, etc. review they have seen/read, what they usually mean (sometimes without realising it) is that it is the one that most closely matches their own opinions.

 

Reviews (good or bad) are more often subjective than objective, as are peoples' opinions (that's just human nature).

didn't like the reviewers. blabbing all the way. making idiotic jokes.

not professional. the point of any review is list pros and cons of the release in concise way.

here just tons useless trash talk.

aimed at toilet level.

Translation: I found a review I agree with therefore it's realistic and accurate.

 

 

I don't care for reviews, good or bad. I form my own opinion by playing.

 

Exactly.

Sorry finished the video and all I heard was 45 minutes of...

 

"Why can't I?"

 

Why can't I do this? Why can't I do that? This is too linear for me.

 

Then this game isn't for you, doesn't mean this game it bad it just doesn't suite your tastes. If you don't like the game that's fine all well and good.

 

Also I'd feel like he was less bias if he friend just played, shut up and followed instructions from the viewer and better yet.... LET THE REVIEWER PLAY.

Wow a vid of two guys in a bedroom voicing their opinion on a game....if i wanted someone's review i would read up from paid professionals, not two nobodys that have played wow:rolleyes:

You really need to get your facts straight before you quote someone, bud.

 

1. It is 45 mins long and you're on the forums which suggests you have NOTHING to do at this time.

 

2. I didn't call it a review the OP did, but 3 minutes in I could tell that it's not a review it's a first impression..there is a difference, educate yourself please.

 

3. I'm not the OP so why are you even saying this?

 

1) Nice assumption. Maybe I'm outside smoking a cig in between playing the game and have a couple minutes to burn (read "not 45").

 

2) I'm well educated, thank you. Your incorrect punctuation and argumentum ad hominem makes me question your ability to reason, however.

 

3) I hit quote on accident, instead of reply. But thanks for jumping down my throat for it.

doesn't mean this game it bad it just doesn't suit your tastes.

 

I wish more people understood this difference.