Fix your lore!

Oh and Consular's CAN become Shadows.

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Jedi_Covenant

"The Jedi Covenant was a secret organization of Jedi headquartered on Coruscant in the time of the Old Sith Wars. It was established after the end of the Great Sith War by Krynda Draay, who felt that it was her failing for not sensing the fall of Exar Kun to the dark side. The Covenant's goal was to use Jedi Consulars as Shadows to search for a shatterpoint that might lead to the resurrection of the Sith, and then take any action necessary to prevent that. The Covenant hated the Sith with a passion, which in itself was an aberration of the Jedi Code. They believed that had such an organization existed before the Sith War, they could have recognized the threat posed by Exar Kun when he was still a Jedi."

He's already used it a couple times to dismiss the light side Sith and dark side Jedi that exist, like Darth Gravid or, I suppose, the entire body of Dark Jedi.

I meant in reference to other posters. In a thread like this, I've never seen it not happen.

/popcorn

As far as the game yes, this is true but if you will look on the specialization from the Jedi lore it is a bit different, which I think is what he is talking about:

Jedi Guardian

Specs for a Guardian:

Jedi Ace
Lightsaber Instructors
Jedi Weapon Masters

Jedi Consular:

Jedi Ambassor
Jedi Diplomat
Jedi Healer

Jedi Sentinel:

Jedi Investigator
Jedi Shadow
Jedi Watchman


I believe this is what he is wishing SWTOR would fix since the Shadow essentially is in the Jedi Sentinel line.

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Jedi


A Jedi Knight is or was essentially a title all Jedi could achieve through their trials.

But of course that is now all legends so not sure how that would relate.

That's basically what I was alluding to. Most "Lore" is non-canon now.

there are people in this forum arguing that cannon isnt cannon anymore...

Fixed, lol:
But basically it is true. Disney declared only certain produced media to be considered as Canon. A lot of the novels, games, etc that had become the "canon" backdrop of the Star Wars universe was declared to be "Legends." Under this name, it basically says that the material is no longer canon, but could be considered canon if any new material affirms it.

It's not so much an argument. It is an actual decision made by Disney.

Source

Everyone knows about legends and whatnot, I'm referring to how every special snowflake is arguing the parts of stories they like should be cannon or don't like shouldn't be, I have no opinion as I don't believe in Star Wars as a continuous narrative without flaws.

Allow me to ask you a question. Do you have a reason for this expectation/demand other than the fact that "all the other Sith are full dark side!!!" ? Do you have a reason beyond that for why a Sith couldn't be more attuned to the light side? Because I'll be completely honest with you: putting everything else aside, that's a terrible argument.

Yes because the Sith would kill the light user the Sith that started on his path to the darkside would be hooked on it like heroin and its been explained multiple times in different pages once down the dark path its extremely unlikely they will be light again (on their own)