Please upgrade your browser for the best possible experience.

Chrome Firefox Internet Explorer
×

Hatred Sins most OP spec in HISTORY of SWTOR

STAR WARS: The Old Republic > English > PvP
Hatred Sins most OP spec in HISTORY of SWTOR

headshot_hendo's Avatar


headshot_hendo
02.02.2015 , 11:25 AM | #391
Yes it is strong but not nerf worthy.

The biggest issue right now is the loss of cleanses.


Yes I want cleanses back. It adds skill to healing. You no longer just spam heal moves and kite.

We may be on the same page honestly but do any of you feel like regaining cleanses will balance things out?

(Has nothing to do with sin)

headshot_hendo's Avatar


headshot_hendo
02.02.2015 , 11:28 AM | #392
Quote: Originally Posted by DrWeebs View Post
I didn't post for 4 days because I was powerleveling an assassin from 0-60 in one week. I did it in less than 2.5 days /played. That takes focus, and I didn't read half of the threads on here (I didn't even realize it blew up so big).

I actually do see your point on snipers. It would be an interesting counter, especially on more open maps like tatooine, but maps like orbital they might have trouble due to LOS possibilities.

It is clear that nobody on this thread agrees with you... you're getting a lot of responses with disagreement. You must like that type of attention.

Most likely, neither of us is better than the other. The skill-cap in this game is extremely low once you get good at it. The 1.5s GCD makes sure of that.
All animosity aside, the double MM accuracy debuff comp is the smartest and most impressive application of utility I have ever come across. Unbelievably impressed with how well it works.

The team we faced is too smart to be pulled out of an advantageous position. They can wait and just clean your team in gas. They win enough so no point in being aggressive when you can wait and win. Even with LOS as a sin you have 3 cds that save you somewhat and they have long cds except phase walk.

Stealth is 1:30 which stops the 14-18k ambushes. Deflection is 2 minutes and phase walk is 45 seconds so it gets rough but ive never had so much fun losing. They split dps a bit and when one gets low stun tank and pile ambushes snipes and followthroughs on the unguarded player. They like sins so usually first to die.

I agree with you, but claiming to be top dps on bastion is ignorant. As for support ive gotten plenty until now when #threaddead and we strayed from the subject at hand.

You have some points I agree with but we differ on the nerf policy. I get it the exaggerated title brings thread views and gets your message out there. I think if BW brings back cleanses it will even things out. It was the dumbest decision BW made, it tops the CC market and the insane amount of small servers at launch that still couldnt handle the lower populations.

DrWeebs's Avatar


DrWeebs
02.02.2015 , 11:33 AM | #393
Quote: Originally Posted by KingKalbo View Post
All this chest-thumping about how OP someone is on an overpowered to begin with class..C'mon people; keep it in the realm of realism. Discuss realistic ways to bring it in line with others or buff the UP classes to viability. Gives me something to read while I'm at work anyway.
The original point of this thread was to not just say that this spec is OP, but it might be the most OP spec this game has ever seen. That was my original argument.

I have tried to explore that theory/opinion by powerleveling an assassin to 60 in a week and jumping right into pvp. My findings are that I completely dominate almost every match, whether it's ranked/regs, 4v4 or 8v8. I almost never lose on this toon. My other main 60 is a sorc, and I can pull high numbers sometimes, I can burst well from distance, have some good kiting tools, etc. But my actual effectiveness for changing fights and winning big teamfights/ranked 4v4's is far better on the assassin. I feel more effective than I ever have in this game, and I've played many specs, including 1.x conceal op, roflsmash, hybrid jugg, lethality sniper, 3.x lightning sorc that everyone complaints about as OP. I used to play at a fairly high level in this game when 8v8 ranked was here... and since still popped in and out and casually played 4's.

This without a doubt the most OP I have ever felt. Not even remotely close.

I agree other classes need buffs to come in line, but hatred also needs some moderate nerfs. I like the idea of dot spread, but healers need more abilities to cleanse their team of them, and I think either nerf hatred burst a bit (assassinate damage), or nerf deflection (it's 12s of 50% damage reduction and cc immunity with utility).
Prïapism - Assassin
Humpherie - Sorc
Bärtleby - Jugg
Bastion Server

headshot_hendo's Avatar


headshot_hendo
02.02.2015 , 11:43 AM | #394
Quote: Originally Posted by DrWeebs View Post
The original point of this thread was to not just say that this spec is OP, but it might be the most OP spec this game has ever seen. That was my original argument.

I have tried to explore that theory/opinion by powerleveling an assassin to 60 in a week and jumping right into pvp. My findings are that I completely dominate almost every match, whether it's ranked/regs, 4v4 or 8v8. I almost never lose on this toon. My other main 60 is a sorc, and I can pull high numbers sometimes, I can burst well from distance, have some good kiting tools, etc. But my actual effectiveness for changing fights and winning big teamfights/ranked 4v4's is far better on the assassin. I feel more effective than I ever have in this game, and I've played many specs, including 1.x conceal op, roflsmash, hybrid jugg, lethality sniper, 3.x lightning sorc that everyone complaints about as OP. I used to play at a fairly high level in this game when 8v8 ranked was here... and since still popped in and out and casually played 4's.

This without a doubt the most OP I have ever felt. Not even remotely close.

I agree other classes need buffs to come in line, but hatred also needs some moderate nerfs. I like the idea of dot spread, but healers need more abilities to cleanse their team of them, and I think either nerf hatred burst a bit (assassinate damage), or nerf deflection (it's 12s of 50% damage reduction and cc immunity with utility).
Why do you need to nerf the survivability? Its kinda what players asked for. TBH. I seem to remember people raging about resolve and "Stun Wars". I think giving everyone else immunity as well will make things better. The game wont rely on stuns anymore. It will rely on damage, hard swaps, focus, and skilled healing. Thats what I want if anything.

Now playing a Sin you cant honestly say it wouldnt be nice if all the other classes gained an immunity of the same caliber.

DrWeebs's Avatar


DrWeebs
02.02.2015 , 11:52 AM | #395
Quote: Originally Posted by headshot_hendo View Post
Why do you need to nerf the survivability? Its kinda what players asked for. TBH. I seem to remember people raging about resolve and "Stun Wars". I think giving everyone else immunity as well will make things better. The game wont rely on stuns anymore. It will rely on damage, hard swaps, focus, and skilled healing. Thats what I want if anything.

Now playing a Sin you cant honestly say it wouldnt be nice if all the other classes gained an immunity of the same caliber.
I guess I targeted deflection because it is a major reason why assassins are so strong, particularly in 4v4. For example, as a sorc, I get stunned up and don't have any damage mitigation, only self-healing... am forced to "oh ****" kite a lot and it is easy to remove me as a threat. As an assassin, I pop out of stealth and if any sign of threat pop deflection and be cc immune and 50% damage reduction for 12s while I put massive pressure on the other team. It's not fun to go against an assassin who uses their DCD's well... it's a very tough match-up for anyone.
Prïapism - Assassin
Humpherie - Sorc
Bärtleby - Jugg
Bastion Server

BenjtheFox's Avatar


BenjtheFox
02.02.2015 , 02:34 PM | #396
Quote: Originally Posted by DrWeebs View Post
I have played PVP in every form since release, including the now dead ranked 8v8. Hatred assassins as they are now, are probably the most overpowered spec in the history of this game. The only things that come close are 1.0 conceal operatives that could global people out of stealth and were quickly nerfed 3-4x in each subsequent patch, 2.0 operative healers. Marauders in early 8v8 ranked were pretty OP, but nothing on the level of where hatred assassins are now.

To even try to argue that hatred assassins are not OP is ignorant at best, and otherwise dishonest.
They are capable of the top DPS in the game, pulling 3k+ DPS in warzones. This is fine, someone has to be the dop DPS parser in warzones and put out that pressure on the other team. However, the top DPS shouldn't also have the game's second best defensive CD's (2nd only to juggernaut) with 7s of force shroud available, deflect, CC immunity, combined with stealth/combat re-stealth, self-heals, force speed with CC breaker, extreme DOT pressure with assassinate ability.

No other spec in the history of the game has had the combination of survivability + damage + stealth. Not even remotely close.

PT/Sorc/Veng Jugg are all very strong specs, and honestly I think that's where the balance should be. Classes that are weaker than them need to be buffed. The only class that needs to be nerfed are hatred assassins. They have literally broken ranked warzones.

I am fine going against a PT who can blow me up in a matter of seconds because they have weaknesses that I can exploit. They are squishy and not very mobile. Oh, and they're not stealth. Sorcs are very killable, they are like fighting a piece of paper, and thundering blast is interruptable. They are also... not stealth. Juggernauts are tanky, but just make them blow their DCD's and they do NOT put out the type of damage pressure an assassin does, oh yea and they are not stealth.

More and more and more wz's are just full of assassins. I even considered being that guy and no-lifing an assassin up to 60 because they're just so so so strong right now. They are without a doubt the most OP PVP spec this game has ever had in its 3+ year history.

Hatred Assassins need to be nerfed for the good of the game.
I realize I'm coming into this thread 30 pages in, but I did look through several pages looking for some video links, but I just can't find them.

OP, do you have any videos of the OP Hated Assassin facerolling everyone and everything? Because all I can say is that I haven't noticed this in 50+ games of P VP on the Ebon Hawk, and I'd be interested in seeing what you're talking about.

Evolixe's Avatar


Evolixe
02.02.2015 , 02:35 PM | #397
Quote: Originally Posted by headshot_hendo View Post
Que ranked on harbinger ill give you my spot here if youd like. Up to you. You cant honestly claim you can beat people youve never faced.
Been there done that.

I've pretty much seen the entire playerbase as far as it goes for good players.
And there is not a single sniper who would even come halfway close to endangering me.

Besides, I have 280ms latency on the Harbinger. So thanks but no thanks.
You can come to JC, take any sniper you want along with you, and I will show you how to really play a sin.
Evolixe | Exilove
Darth Malgus
Watch me live on Twitch

EnzoForMe's Avatar


EnzoForMe
02.02.2015 , 02:50 PM | #398
Quote: Originally Posted by Evolixe View Post
Been there done that.

I've pretty much seen the entire playerbase as far as it goes for good players.
And there is not a single sniper who would even come halfway close to endangering me.

Besides, I have 280ms latency on the Harbinger. So thanks but no thanks.
You can come to JC, take any sniper you want along with you, and I will show you how to really play a sin.
Tehe.

I support the fact that Harbinger blows as a server tho.
Caprica
#1 Team Ranked Sniper: Seasons 3 and 6
#1 Solo Ranked Gunslinger: Seasons 2, 8, and 10

Evolixe's Avatar


Evolixe
02.02.2015 , 02:51 PM | #399
Quote: Originally Posted by EnzoForMe View Post
Tehe.
Including you.
Evolixe | Exilove
Darth Malgus
Watch me live on Twitch

EnzoForMe's Avatar


EnzoForMe
02.02.2015 , 02:52 PM | #400
Quote: Originally Posted by Evolixe View Post
Including you.
No idea who you are. haven't seen you in the past 2 seasons of ranked on pot5 but come and school me anytime. The fact that you said "come to JC" is what made me lol. Server was fun in the days of 8s but it's a cesspool now.

My team played pretty much exclusively against double maddness sins or double pyro pt last season until they quit playing against us half way through the season with 1 team as an exception. It's nothing new.
Caprica
#1 Team Ranked Sniper: Seasons 3 and 6
#1 Solo Ranked Gunslinger: Seasons 2, 8, and 10