Please upgrade your browser for the best possible experience.

Chrome Firefox Internet Explorer
×

Ideas to balance the overpowerd assassins, and madness sorcerers.

STAR WARS: The Old Republic > English > PvP
Ideas to balance the overpowerd assassins, and madness sorcerers.

JediMasterSLC's Avatar


JediMasterSLC
09.04.2014 , 12:32 PM | #291
Quote: Originally Posted by JackNader View Post
Look... let's straighten things up because I am pretty everyone is missing my point.

My toon is low in level. It is presently 35. I know from playing dumbception for ages that over force regeneration is as much of a waste as spamming high force attacks. I also know the value of opening burst vs going straight into a sustained rotation.

When i am opening up on people I am at 100 force. I also have Dark Embrace which is 50% force regeneration. If I go straight into a deathfield -> discharge -> thrash -> Crushing darkness.. my opening damage is meh. The crushing darkness cast also over regenerates my force pool. In other words I am at 100 force the moment I cast crushing darkness and I've just wasted force (~ at least 15 force).

If I choose to go deathfield ->discharge -> maul -> crushing darkness... my force pool is around 80 force.

That's why I'm doing it. I am not suggesting people run around spamming maul maul maul lol. Now later on when I have more abilities, things might change. I won't know until I am at that point. The entire reason I am leveling this new sin through madness is so I can make an informed opinion on the spec.
Don't get dark embrace.

Tellenn's Avatar


Tellenn
09.04.2014 , 12:33 PM | #292
Quote: Originally Posted by JackNader View Post
Is lightning burns bugged? I am at the dummy now testing force regen. The ability states that lightning charge and crushing darkness have a 100% chance to apply lightning burns to the target dealing X amount of damage and recovering 2 force after 1 second.. Crushing darkness doesn't appear to be procing lightning burns at all. Bug?
Lightning Burns procs from Creeping Terror (sin) Lightning Strike (sorc) not Crushing Darkness
Makabe 55 Sage~Sondaica 55 Shadow~Velosa 55 Guard~Kambai 55 Sent~Arcker 55 Sling~Zemisor 3X Mando
Ankus 55 Sorc~Janas 55 Sin~Aminos 55 Jug~Xaninos 3X Mara~Kastius 55 PT~Yunoss 55 Op
Telen Legacy::The Red Eclipse

JackNader's Avatar


JackNader
09.04.2014 , 12:36 PM | #293
Quote: Originally Posted by Tellenn View Post
Lightning Burns procs from Creeping Terror (sin) Lightning Strike (sorc) not Crushing Darkness
Ok thanks.. misread tool tip

Zoom_VI's Avatar


Zoom_VI
09.04.2014 , 12:42 PM | #294
Quote: Originally Posted by JackNader View Post
If I choose to go deathfield ->discharge -> maul -> crushing darkness... my force pool is around 80 force.
Thrash > maul if you're not deception. They do roughly similar damage. Yes maul means you won't top out on force, but using maul gains you nothings, you might as well top out on force.
Crinn

Sanity is for the weak minded.

JediMasterSLC's Avatar


JediMasterSLC
09.04.2014 , 12:49 PM | #295
Quote: Originally Posted by Tellenn View Post
Interrupt FL and its locked out for 4s more if specced into lockout extension (which you should if in your spec tree). Without it you have to hard cast or dot someone else. Dotting is force intensive and you need to rotate a FL to keep your force up. Interrupt their FL and they can't get an instant CD which is their key damaging ability and will have to hard cast it unless they are holding onto wrath and missing out LS.

FL is boosted on the target affected by its CT dot. So its no use for target switching. Outside proccing wrath and its 50% snare its just a filler between your CD to use on your CT target to hold onto your force for your next deathmark rotation.

The only time FL evers hit hard is when cast twice under reckless and PS on your CT target. So that once every 90/120s.
What spec has lockout extension besides lightning? I hardly think that's worth mentioning.

Oh no if your FL gets interrupted your only options are shock, stun, slow, KB, self heal, bubble, affliction, CT, LS if you have 3 stacks and CD isn't up for another 7+ seconds (you never ever cast CD), ww, cleanse, extricate... but I'm sure all of those abilities will either be on CD or not useful at the time, especially since afflictioning someone else (if your primary target's affliction isn't expired or about to expire of course) costs force and shouldn't be used right? -_-. Madness has it really rough man.

JediMasterSLC's Avatar


JediMasterSLC
09.04.2014 , 12:52 PM | #296
Quote: Originally Posted by Zoom_VI View Post
Thrash > maul if you're not deception. They do roughly similar damage. Yes maul means you won't top out on force, but using maul gains you nothings, you might as well top out on force.
Yes, but you should just CT or assassinate with a lucky early proc before CD lol, as its functional CD is time in between procs, not when you actually use it (oh wait I forgot you gotta go for that l33t burst that people play madness for).

Yeah don't take force regen talent. Get CDR talent in deception, 5/2/39.

Tellenn's Avatar


Tellenn
09.04.2014 , 01:01 PM | #297
Quote: Originally Posted by JediMasterSLC View Post
What spec has lockout extension besides lightning? I hardly think that's worth mentioning.

Oh no if your FL gets interrupted your only options are shock, stun, slow, KB, self heal, bubble, affliction, CT, LS if you have 3 stacks and CD isn't up for another 7+ seconds (you never ever cast CD), ww, cleanse, extricate... but I'm sure all of those abilities will either be on CD or not useful at the time, especially since afflictioning someone else (if your primary target's affliction isn't expired or about to expire of course) costs force and shouldn't be used right? -_-. Madness has it really rough man.
Most of those cost force and as you should know managing force is the key to playing madness. You dont waste force particularly on dots without deathmarks up. FL is your force management ability. Its a channel. Hits for hardly anything outside Reckless or without boost on your CT target. So yes if you let a madness sorc free cast and dont interupt his FL then hes going to be able to manage his force.

Interrupt FL and keep him moving. He'll run out of force fast.

Funny thing is there are plenty of tips in this thread to deal with madness sorc/sin. Still you won't bother using any of them you'll just qq and refuse to get better.
Makabe 55 Sage~Sondaica 55 Shadow~Velosa 55 Guard~Kambai 55 Sent~Arcker 55 Sling~Zemisor 3X Mando
Ankus 55 Sorc~Janas 55 Sin~Aminos 55 Jug~Xaninos 3X Mara~Kastius 55 PT~Yunoss 55 Op
Telen Legacy::The Red Eclipse

Zoom_VI's Avatar


Zoom_VI
09.04.2014 , 01:24 PM | #298
Quote: Originally Posted by Tellenn View Post
Most of those cost force and as you should know managing force is the key to playing madness. You dont waste force particularly on dots without deathmarks up. FL is your force management ability. Its a channel. Hits for hardly anything outside Reckless or without boost on your CT target. So yes if you let a madness sorc free cast and dont interupt his FL then hes going to be able to manage his force.

Interrupt FL and keep him moving. He'll run out of force fast.

Funny thing is there are plenty of tips in this thread to deal with madness sorc/sin. Still you won't bother using any of them you'll just qq and refuse to get better.
Madness force management is tight, buts its not that tight.

The whole point of my post is that getting the three stacks required for CD is ludicrously easy and nearly impossible to stop. You should be required to finish the channel entirely, or at the very least the stacks should expire rapidly.
Crinn

Sanity is for the weak minded.

Tevzz's Avatar


Tevzz
09.04.2014 , 01:49 PM | #299
Quote: Originally Posted by MusicRider View Post
The knowledge that people that played ranked warzones is valuable and some of it applicable even in arenas. Do you think hard-switches is a new thing that was introduced with arenas?
You said that Madness sorcs weren't fine in ranked warzones a few pages ago. But that's irrelevant because Ranked WZs don't exist anymore and the reason Madness got its buffs had NOTHING to do with ranked warzones, bringing up Madness sorcs' performance in ranked WZ's was something you did, and something that has absolutely nothing to do with the issue at hand because ranked warzones are not relevant to class balance at all anymore.

Quote:
Wow. Applause. Where have you been? Next time someone asks whether madness has burst I will refer to your post. A 6k hit which is not an autocrit followed by what exactly?
Good, then you can stop talking about how madness has no on demand burst in your posts and use that as an excuse for why the buffs were valid because it isn't supposed to have any.
Spoiler

Now that we agree on this, we can hopefully never mention Madness spec and its burst, because its non-existent.

Quote:
Yes OK. I have already established that you have no clue about sorcs... Keep on using blindly CL and DF for burst on the hybrid. Did I mention that I was playing this hybrid in the form of 25/16 in ranked before 2.0 when none knew about it?
Lol the hybrid has much higher burst potential than madness, although being a more AoE oriented spec. I wonder though, as such a sorc expert what do you use for burst with that hybrid. Force Lightning and Lightning strike?

Quote:
Also why are we discussing the hybrid?
Because we were talking about burst and sorcs? Link between topics? And seeing how madness has none, that leaves us with Full Lightning, which has considerable single target burst with the TB auto-crit but is dam easy to screw over and the hybrid which is as "bursty" as sorcs get if they're not specced full lightning.

Quote:
I am pretty sure that has been resolved on pts... GG. BB. Stop QQing, I am bored to death now.
Nothing got resolved lol, go read PTS notes -__- if anything sorcs get an optional extra 2-3% mitigation as well as UP's GCD removed along with other less important stuff. Nothing of the passage you quoted has been "resolved", not that it needs to, because Ranked strats and team comps aren't the issue at hand. Much resolving such wow, you totally have a clue what you're talking about
Vanov - CarnageVanôv - VengeanceDarrthvanov - DeceptionVânôv - FocusVa'nov - APVânov - Concealment
The Shadowlands - Reading Rainbow - Triumph

JediMasterSLC's Avatar


JediMasterSLC
09.04.2014 , 02:29 PM | #300
Quote: Originally Posted by Tellenn View Post
FL ... Hits for hardly anything outside Reckless or without boost on your CT target
You are deluding yourself.

I played 10-15 group ranked games as madness sorc last night and have hundreds of games of group ranked experience with the spec during S1- I'm not exactly personally biased against it. I say they're OP because I care about balance and they're OP. I think I am allowed to speak as to how easy and relatively uncounterable the spec is if I take 600k damage in one round with constant hard stuns and still do top dmg with it. The only way your force is really going to get ****ed up within the span of a 4s round is if the other team completely rides your dick and is constantly interrupting and ccing you during your FL like it's their job... in which case, they deserve to reap what they have sown via your DPS being significantly lowered. You are just whining that the other team can take steps to lower madness's ridiculous output. L2P.