Pay to Win

Oh i would like to see how the community will react if Bioware will release stims and buffs that give you an advatage. You know so casuals have better chances of clearing the NiM modes and in the same time they can make them harder for those progression guilds that don't want to use those BiS stims and buffs.
Bioware should give it a try.
This would also be a good training for their PR guys as they could try to write more awesome blog posts that explain that this is no P2W.
I would guess that it is even ok to sell the best gear and make modifications and stuff available via cc so you can optimize you stats with real money. No need for crafters. You can sell everything in the GTN of course.
As nothing that is PvE content can be P2W we should also add grade 8 space ship parts to cm only.
And why bother with PvP sell the best stuff in the cm. PvP is secondary content anyways so why always the headaches with new gear. Just give everyone the best gear for money and all that is left is skill.
I see great times for BW so much money to make.

it's not a demo
it's way more than a demo would ever offer
it's more than a lot of single player games even offer, 8 story lines with missions and side missions all of it for free

And it's also barely playable. I highly doubt someone would go through awful combat mechanics just to see a two second tack on story that BW threw together. And before we get there, just because you are willing to deal with a nerfed mmo doesn't mean everyone else will. In fact most people haven't.

If you are not willing to play it with the restrictions, buy a subscription, it's that easy

Or get one of the far superior mmos out there completely free. Enjoy having a big EA logo stamped on your forehead.

So based on your examples of why TOR is P2W, let's look at some of the other freemium MMOs you mentioned in this thread:

LOTRO is P2W because F2P players have a 2 gold limit, they only get a couple of trait slots, and cannot earn rest XP.
Rift is P2W because subscribers get 15% more currency and daily XP/reputation boosts.
Tera is P2W because subscribers get daily XP, gold, and reputation boosts.
Aion is P2W because F2P players can only gather/extract a limited number of times each day, and their instance cooldowns are much longer.

Subscribers will always get benefits that F2P players don't get; otherwise there would be no point in subscribing. Now you can argue that TOR has more restrictions than other games (and I would actually agree with you on that), but having restrictions doesn't make it P2W. Otherwise every freemium MMO would be P2W.