Please upgrade your browser for the best possible experience.

Chrome Firefox Internet Explorer
×

2.0.1 55 lvl wz bolster fixed or not?

STAR WARS: The Old Republic > English > PvP
2.0.1 55 lvl wz bolster fixed or not?

cripito's Avatar


cripito
04.24.2013 , 01:34 PM | #61
Quote: Originally Posted by MidichIorian View Post
I don't see the problem here. You swap a proc relic for an auged relic with a static amount of stats and you cant comprehend how you're bonus damage is going up? What part of it is it that you don't understand? That's not a bolster problem, that's you having a problem with the new relics.

As for your friend, it has always been a balance. You could drop some PvP items too and get a higher main stat. I don't see how it's any different from what people did in 1.7 (power crystals instead of expertise, PvE armorings etc). You do realize that you lose damage/reduction/healing multiplier when dropping in expertise, right, so that the stats you add have to make up for that loss. I can gain 10 % bonus damage by putting on PvE gear but it's not of much use if my damage multiplier goes down from 60 % to 45 % because of the expertise drop.
Why? why I should drop 7 pieces of conqueror pvp gear for pve gear for PVP? don't you get that's precisally the wrong stuff?

they said they were fixing that in 2.0. I had in 1.7 barrels pve and armorings PVE in bracers and belt.. why?

Covaltage's Avatar


Covaltage
04.24.2013 , 01:36 PM | #62
Quote: Originally Posted by MidichIorian View Post
I don't get the whole wh/ewh entitlement claim. EWH/WH is 5 levels old gear when you ding 55, it shouldnt be viable, so enough with the whining about having to grind again. You've had two weeks to grind already and if you consider bolster to be such a problem I have to assume that you've actually played to experience this too. Didnt you get a single wz comm in those game? So use those on some new gear then and **** up about it already.
LOL read the thread, nobody here thinks their EWH should still be BiS.

MidichIorian's Avatar


MidichIorian
04.24.2013 , 01:38 PM | #63
Quote: Originally Posted by Covaltage View Post
LOL read the thread, nobody here thinks their EWH should still be BiS.
It was aimed at the people who were complaining about having to grind a new PvP set. I never mentioned or even insinuated that anyone had said that WH should be BiS.

Devlonir's Avatar


Devlonir
04.24.2013 , 01:44 PM | #64
Quote: Originally Posted by cripito View Post
Why? why I should drop 7 pieces of conqueror pvp gear for pve gear for PVP? don't you get that's precisally the wrong stuff?

they said they were fixing that in 2.0. I had in 1.7 barrels pve and armorings PVE in bracers and belt.. why?
You clearly aren't understanding the point he makes. Let me make it simple:

Your PVP gear at 2018 EXP has 5% more expertise than your PVE geared friend.

That 5% more expertise gives you a lot more than 5% extra base stats does. Therefore, your gear is stronger, even if the simple stats (main + endurance) don't say it that directly.

That's why his initial point was: Bolster and Expertise is too complex for people to understand that they actually have an advantage when they claim the other one has.
"Cows go 'Moo', Dogs go 'Woof', MMO Players go 'The PVP is unbalanced!" - Yahthzee
"I'm starting to get the feeling that BW and their MMO are not the dysfunctional ones." - Rafaman

BoushhDC's Avatar


BoushhDC
04.24.2013 , 01:48 PM | #65
Quote: Originally Posted by MidichIorian View Post
I don't get the whole wh/ewh entitlement claim. EWH/WH is 5 levels old gear when you ding 55, it shouldnt be viable, so enough with the whining about having to grind again. You've had two weeks to grind already and if you consider bolster to be such a problem I have to assume that you've actually played to experience this too. Didnt you get a single wz comm in those game? So use those on some new gear then and **** up about it already.
Is Campaign gear still viable? Is there a vendor that still sells it? S the F Up

The point is this: before 2.0 was released to live (for the pre-orders) the devs said that WH/EWH, as it was with Expertise on it, would be viable. A week after it went live, they said that although they were having issues, that it "would again be viable!" Then, several days later when the patch came, they stealth stripped Expertise off it w/ the exceptions of the relics and removing the crystals from the main & offhand weapon pieces --- the latter, btw, was something they had previously said would be a problem in the bolster system: having an item w/ Expertise in one slot, but not all. The removal of Expertise from WH/EWH gear WAS NOT THE DESIGN, it was NOT what was intended. They just threw a Hail Mary at the Eleventh hour because they didn't know what else to do because of their problems. Quit acting as though that was the plan all along. They were screwed and couldn't fix it.
All men can see these tactics whereby I conquer, but what none can see is the strategy out of which victory is evolved. --Sun Tzu

Astarica's Avatar


Astarica
04.24.2013 , 01:48 PM | #66
The problem is that most people can't do math to account for the overall effect of expertise. Of course your numbers must go up if you replace same tier PvP gear with same tier PvE gear, otherwise they wouldn't even be a point to have PvE gear. Full Conqueror = 60% mod, while full UW = ~40% mod. So with full conqueror say your autoattack says it does 1000 tool tip damage, but it's really 1600 damage to another player. With full UW, your tool tip damage may say it does 1100 damage, but it's really 1100 * 1.4 = 1540 damage to another player. Likewise replacing Partisan with blue 66 gear will usually result the tooltip number going up, because blue 66 gear still have less expertise than Partisan gear and even a very small amount of it has a significant effect. The Partisan power proc relic (~435 power?) is only worth 7% more tooltip damage when it's on.

I'm seeing people basically saying like "I got 100 more mainstat and endurance and only lost 200 expertise, how can that possibly be worse?' Well 200 expertise is a 6% mod. 100 endurance is 1000 HP, and hopefully that is not 6% of your HP (that'd mean your max HP is 16666). Likewise I'd hope 100 mainstat isn't 6% of your DPS as that'd imply your DPS is ridiculously low to begin with. If you use 30K HP as a convenient base line, 1000 HP is 3.3% HP, so 100 endurance is only worth 110 expertise and that's overlooking the fact that reducing damage is always superior to increasing HPs by the same % because heals are usually not % based.

Covaltage's Avatar


Covaltage
04.24.2013 , 01:53 PM | #67
Quote: Originally Posted by MidichIorian View Post
It was aimed at the people who were complaining about having to grind a new PvP set. I never mentioned or even insinuated that anyone had said that WH should be BiS.
Nobody cares that they have to grind a new PvP set. We had a level increase, we all understand it's time to grind new gear. Thing is, we can't tell if grinding new gear is worth it due to bolster. It's really difficult to justify grinding up Partisan gear right now due to it's marginal stat increase and the massive expertise bolster applied to PvE gear.

cripito's Avatar


cripito
04.24.2013 , 01:56 PM | #68
Quote: Originally Posted by Devlonir View Post
You clearly aren't understanding the point he makes. Let me make it simple:

Your PVP gear at 2018 EXP has 5% more expertise than your PVE geared friend.

That 5% more expertise gives you a lot more than 5% extra base stats does. Therefore, your gear is stronger, even if the simple stats (main + endurance) don't say it that directly.

That's why his initial point was: Bolster and Expertise is too complex for people to understand that they actually have an advantage when they claim the other one has.
No .. you are not getting the point.. read the xp when you mouse over.. 2018 give u 2% dmg boost more and 1% more dmg reduction that my friend in gear 66 with 1920 xp ... no even in 69 or 72..

Crawelc's Avatar


Crawelc
04.24.2013 , 01:59 PM | #69
Quote: Originally Posted by cripito View Post
No .. you are not getting the point.. read the xp when you mouse over.. 2018 give u 2% dmg boost more and 1% more dmg reduction that my friend in gear 66 ... no even in 69 or 72..
If this is true than this is still broken, 5% for the highest tier of pve gear would be about right. 2% for a mid tier set is abominable. JUST REMOVE BOLSTER FROM 55 WZS!
Imprimis
All Imprimis All the time.

MidichIorian's Avatar


MidichIorian
04.24.2013 , 02:04 PM | #70
Quote: Originally Posted by Covaltage View Post
Nobody cares that they have to grind a new PvP set. We had a level increase, we all understand it's time to grind new gear. Thing is, we can't tell if grinding new gear is worth it due to bolster. It's really difficult to justify grinding up Partisan gear right now due to it's marginal stat increase and the massive expertise bolster applied to PvE gear.
You only have to skip to page one to find atleast one person complaining about having to grind again.

I don't really get what the problem is here. Are people just playing for comms? If they are playing anyway they're eventually going to have enough comms for a set. That set might not be significally better than the top PvE set but it's atleast not worse and it's better than the WH set. If they rather play operations for UW they're free to do so instead.

Actually, I know what the problem is. The problem is that people expect to have like 50 % better stats on their PvP gear compared to someone in PvE gear because that's the only way they can "pwn newbs".