Please upgrade your browser for the best possible experience.

Chrome Firefox Internet Explorer
×

The BattleZone! Round 1 Match 03: Lord Vitiate vs. Darth Plagueis

STAR WARS: The Old Republic > English > STAR WARS Discussion
The BattleZone! Round 1 Match 03: Lord Vitiate vs. Darth Plagueis

Darkondo's Avatar


Darkondo
04.03.2013 , 09:38 AM | #81
Quote: Originally Posted by Kaedusz View Post
@Baniboybling ,The jedi knight protagonist defeated the Voice,not the original.And he is also one of the most powerful jedi ever.
This is actually a controversial and debatable subject due to a statement made by Hall Hood, the lead writer of the JK story stating that he defeated the Emperor vs. an email you get from the Emperor's hand as well as the emperor's original body being sith pureblood.

I have no doubt that he just defeated the Voice, however this part is still debatable and a wait and see before we actually know the truth.

Beniboybling's Avatar


Beniboybling
04.03.2013 , 09:42 AM | #82
Quote: Originally Posted by Kaedusz View Post
@Baniboybling ,The jedi knight protagonist defeated the Voice,not the original.And he is also one of the most powerful jedi ever.
As Darkondo says, highly debatable. And I am of the opinion it was the real Emperor and that the Emperor is dead.

Kaedusz's Avatar


Kaedusz
04.03.2013 , 09:44 AM | #83
Plagueis is no way ,i mean *no way*, even close to a guy that consumed a planet and that much sith lords of which at least 100 of them are real powerful.And Sidious who's feats after the movies is under construction (even if he is still alive) is,but that is another topic best left for another thread.

Also i imagine consuming other beings and the force out of them is something not that old by the time he did it which means he is a dark side pioneer in that regard.And he is not a wound in force like Nihilus which means you must have great will focus and power to screw an entire planet with that much sith,even if were easily exploited because of the situation they are in and they lend part of their power to Vitiate..

Rule of Two in our context means only that the next sith is more powerful than his Master.Just because there are 2 ,and only 2 beings use the dark side,doesn't mean they are by default godlike compared to the ancient sith.Power not being deluded is not said fully in a context of force ability.Which means -yea- you overestimate Plagueis.

Beniboybling's Avatar


Beniboybling
04.03.2013 , 09:55 AM | #84
Quote: Originally Posted by Darkondo View Post
Actually, only Tol Braga and the Hero of Tython managed to resist the initial storm the other 3 were incapacitated. And even so, it still slowed down them both immensely to where Vitiate could throw a burst of lightning with no issue. Again, Vitiate wasnt trying to kill any of the jedi strike team, only subdue and either enslave them with mind control, or break them to his cause.

1. Without force bellow a change up would be necessary as he still needs to move his hands back to actually project a force wave. There is a possibility that he could move his hands back to where he is still maintaining his tutamis, however this can also put him at an even GREATER risk and heres why.
- Remember in the Revan novel, while Revan was containing Vitiate's lightning even when he was holding it and it wasnt leaking out, the sheer heat from Vitiate's lightning was melting Revan's mask into his face. The same could happen to Plagueis if held too long or it got too close to his face, and if that respirator gets damaged then Plagueis loses.

2. Remember, both Plagueis and Vitiate like to play god, meaning they both believe that they are gods and that there is nothing in the universe more powerful then they are. I see this as Plagueis's downfall, since he believes that he cannot be defeated even in a force battle, which he would prefer to wage anyway. Since Plagueis believes himself to be god, and that there is no way that he can be defeated, he sees lightning from Vitiate as simply something he can catch and absorb, which in his mind there is absolutely no way that he is going to be overwhelmed by it since he is god.

With this line of thinking, he proceeds to use tutamis to catch Vitiate's lightning. When he does this one of 3 things can happen.
- The heat from Vitiate's lightning even if he absorbs it all could melt his transpirator, thus killing him regardless if the need to change up is there or if he can use force bellow
- If he does change up, he could still be susceptible to lightning which could damage his transpirator same result
- He can use force bellow, which he may not even be able to use due to his transpirator in the 1st place

I just dont see Plagueis getting out of an initial lightning confrontation which would happen due to both Vitiate's and Plagueis's belief that they are all powerful.
Yes, it did slow them down. But only because they attempted to power through it. If Plagueis were caught in such a storm (which he may simply evade) I suspect he would draw his lightsabers to absorb the attack. We also have to consider the nature of the storm, after re-watching the JK Act 2 ending it seemed that Vitiate was actively prolonging the storm and when Braga and the JK charged him he realised further bolts of energy to push them back. So, in that sense, all Plagueis would have to do is unleashed a Force wave at Vitiate and knock him back or at least stagger him, the storm would peter out and Plagueis would engage him, preventing him from summoning another.

  1. Good point, but telekinetic attacks i.e. throwing objects at him, collapse the ceiling on him, are still on the table. I believe Plagueis would find a way to break the lock, that is if he decided not to dodge it instead. And if he does break the lock, he can respond immediately will an immensely powerful, charged attack.

  2. I'm not sure we can say that Plagueis arrogance extended to the extent your suggesting. There is little evidence that this is the case, while he would definitely be confident he'd also be very much aware of Vitiate's power simply through Force sense. An awareness reinforced when Vitiate starts calling down Force storms and summoning illusions etc. This would make him reassess his tactics and leave no room for error.

Beniboybling's Avatar


Beniboybling
04.03.2013 , 09:56 AM | #85
Quote: Originally Posted by Kaedusz View Post
Plagueis is no way ,i mean *no way*, even close to a guy that consumed a planet and that much sith lords of which at least 100 of them are real powerful.And Sidious who's feats after the movies is under construction (even if he is still alive) is,but that is another topic best left for another thread.

Also i imagine consuming other beings and the force out of them is something not that old by the time he did it which means he is a dark side pioneer in that regard.And he is not a wound in force like Nihilus which means you must have great will focus and power to screw an entire planet with that much sith,even if were easily exploited because of the situation they are in and they lend part of their power to Vitiate..

Rule of Two in our context means only that the next sith is more powerful than his Master.Just because there are 2 ,and only 2 beings use the dark side,doesn't mean they are by default godlike compared to the ancient sith.Power not being deluded is not said fully in a context of force ability.Which means -yea- you overestimate Plagueis.
Did you read my post? That feat was not his own, it was the combined feat of 8000 Sith. Like I said, he can perform clever rituals, not gonna help him much in this battle.

EDIT: And yeah, by dilution of power, he means Force abilities. Tons of Sith attempting to grab hold of dark side secrets, getting killed by other Sith for it, and altogether having little time to hone their abilities because there too busy fighting, means there power is going to be capped. This is not the case with the Rule of Two, which takes the best of the best and makes them better, they have all the dark side knowledge too themselves and are free to explore it at their leisure, then those who come later use the knowledge that their predecessors have collected to become even better. Each Sith is more powerful than the next, by default Plagueis is more powerful than Bane.

Kaedusz's Avatar


Kaedusz
04.03.2013 , 10:06 AM | #86
Quote: Originally Posted by Beniboybling View Post
This is not the case with the Rule of Two, which takes the best of the best and makes them better, then those who come later use the knowledge that their predecessors have collected to become even better. Each Sith is more powerful than the next, by default Plagueis is more powerful than Bane.[/COLOR]
All that is true, but you made it sound like you believe that the Dark Side personally is gonna grand them more power by default just because there are fewer sith, which is absurd.
Also much knowledge was screwed by Darth Gravid,which means that the accumulation of power and force secrets was not in a steady progression and there was a major setback.And it was caused by one of the integral flaws of the Rule of Two at that.
Quote: Originally Posted by Beniboybling View Post
That feat was not his own, it was the combined feat of 8000 Sith
Unless you are a wound in the force you can't consume a planet just like that.
This is immaterial in the first place.All that matters is the power he got after the ritual.

Also there is no way Plagueis can do such a thing without a ritual and help.As i said the things Vitiate do through a ritual,can not be done without it.Plagueis would need a ritual too,if he tries them.

Beniboybling's Avatar


Beniboybling
04.03.2013 , 10:33 AM | #87
Quote: Originally Posted by Kaedusz View Post
All that is true, but you made it sound like you believe that the Dark Side personally is gonna grand them more power by default just because there are fewer sith, which is absurd.
Also much knowledge was screwed by Darth Gravid,which means that the accumulation of power and force secrets was not in a steady progression and there was a major setback.And it was caused by one of the integral flaws of the Rule of Two at that.
That's merely what I was implying. And yes they were set back, but they had several hundred years to recover. However this largely irrelevant, my point is that those 8000 Sith are likely to be fairly standard/weak. The dark side simply doesn't work well with numbers, because simply put, unlike the Jedi the Sith do not share. Its a dog eat dog world.
Quote:
Unless you are a wound in the force you can't consume a planet just like that.
This is immaterial in the first place.All that matters is the power he got after the ritual.

Also there is no way Plagueis can do such a thing without a ritual and help.As i said the things Vitiate do through a ritual,can not be done without it.Plagueis would need a ritual too,if he tries them.
My point exactly, the feat was not that impressive as he only managed to perfom such a feat with heavy assistance from others. But yes, he did absorb their power, and it made him immensely powerful. However that is a vague term, and while we should take it into account his combat ability is a better way to gauge his ability.

In my books Revan + Meetra + Scourge = Vitiate and the Hero of Tython > Vitiate. Powerful bursts of energy can break Vitiate's defenses, his lightning can be blocked, absorbed and redirected, his Force storms can be endured and his illusions can be dispelled. He is by no means invincible, far from it.

Given this information and given the abilities and power Plagueis possess I reckon he is strong enough to defeat the Emperor however he cannot do this by powering through. He needs wit and guile to exploit the Emperor's weaknesses, and being a cerebral Sith Lord he has much of that.

Aurbere's Avatar


Aurbere
04.03.2013 , 10:47 AM | #88
Just got caught up on everything, and I would like to address a few things.

1. Tol Braga's mask was undamaged by Vitiate's lightning. You can argue dev negligence, but we can prove that his mask was undamaged. Had it been damaged or destroyed, Braga would have died because te Empire does not have to proper gases to keep him alive. So yes, Braga's mask was undamaged by lightning used to incapacitate.

However, this is not Braga vs. Vitiate. This is Plagueis vs. Vitiate. So would the full force of Vitiate's lightning damage Plagueis' transpirator? We would have to consider where the bolts hit. If they do hit the transpirator, then yes, I believe the mask would be damaged.

2. Plagueis may find lightsaber combat tedious, but he will not hesitate to use his lightsabers when the fighting starts.

3. Plagueis may lack precognitive abilities, but he has certainly done well without them. Now, if Vitiate were able to sneak up on him, then Plagueis' lack of precog would be a hindrance.

I should probably set my own 'canon' for this like Beni did.
Added Chapter 66 to The Shadows Fall
"Your only hope to survive is to give in to the rage boiling within you, to acknowledge the Dark Side you deny, and tap into it!"--Darth Tyranus

Beniboybling's Avatar


Beniboybling
04.03.2013 , 11:02 AM | #89
Quote: Originally Posted by Aurbere View Post
If they do hit the transpirator, then yes, I believe the mask would be damaged.
Key word there being 'if' - Force resistance, Force speed and Force wave say no. Just throwing it out there.
Quote:
I should probably set my own 'canon' for this like Beni did.
If you do will my canon conflict with your canon? We're going to need a Holocron Continuity Database before you know it! Someone call Leland Chee!

Kaedusz's Avatar


Kaedusz
04.03.2013 , 11:04 AM | #90
Quote: Originally Posted by Beniboybling View Post
[COLOR=#CC9e42] Powerful bursts of energy can break Vitiate's defenses
My wz queue popped so im just gonna add for now that Revan is probably the best in history ,wielder of both the Dark Side and the Light Side at the same time,because of the particularities of his being.Something similar to Windu's Vapaad but much greater in applicability and in magnitude.
That is if you are referring to when he channeled both sides of the force to create ''burst of energy'' against Vitiate, in the novel.