Please upgrade your browser for the best possible experience.

Chrome Firefox Internet Explorer
×

I Am All For Pay To Win, Are You?

STAR WARS: The Old Republic > English > General Discussion
I Am All For Pay To Win, Are You?

Soluss's Avatar


Soluss
08.22.2012 , 02:53 AM | #101
Quote: Originally Posted by CharleyDanger View Post
Damn it! I wish I had a better memory. I listened to a podcast, maybe it was TorWars, and they were talking about P2W. Apparently a guy from Bioware gave an interview to this German MMO podcaster. The German guy brought the idea of P2W up. The guy from Bioware said that P2W would be a disaster in a game like SWTOR. He went on to say it would never happen. ****! I wish I could give a link, but I would put a large sum of money on SWTOR not being P2W.
P2W is subjective to each individual. What one would consider P2W, another would not. I would put money on there being a very fine line of what they put on the store.
James Ohlen: " For 2012 we really want players to feel like they're getting their money's worth. You're going to see so many changes and additions to the Star Wars Universe. It's going to be impressive. We have our Update 1.2 coming in the next week and then after that it's going to continue to roll out month after month. It's exciting."

S_I_T_H_L_O_R_D's Avatar


S_I_T_H_L_O_R_D
08.22.2012 , 02:59 AM | #102
Quote: Originally Posted by CharleyDanger View Post
Damn it! I wish I had a better memory. I listened to a podcast, maybe it was TorWars, and they were talking about P2W. Apparently a guy from Bioware gave an interview to this German MMO podcaster. The German guy brought the idea of P2W up. The guy from Bioware said that P2W would be a disaster in a game like SWTOR. He went on to say it would never happen. ****! I wish I could give a link, but I would put a large sum of money on SWTOR not being P2W.
I have a link to the interview http://www.buffed.de/SWTOR-Star-Wars...tches-1017839/

The video is in english

MadBlue's Avatar


MadBlue
08.22.2012 , 02:59 AM | #103
Quote: Originally Posted by Ratior View Post
Specific P2W items I like:
PvP Stat boosts
PvP XP boosts
Exclusive CE armour with stats enhancements
Exclusive CE weapons with stats boosts
Flying mounts
Very fast speeders
Cartel coins
Datacrons which are difficult to get
Aside from Cartel Coins and XP boosts, none of these things are likely to ... wait ... flying mounts?! Are you serious?!

Gokkus's Avatar


Gokkus
08.22.2012 , 03:05 AM | #104
Anything that you have to have to be competitive that can be bought with real money will greatly increase the chance of me unsubbing.

Likewise the moment I get the feeling they try to scam me out of my money as a sub, I unsub. There has got to be enough reason to have a sub in the first place.
Jolee: I did it all for the Wookiees.
Revan: The Wookiees?
Jolee: The Wookiees!

ZORG's Avatar


ZORG
08.22.2012 , 03:06 AM | #105
Quote: Originally Posted by Dagor-Dagorath View Post
My circumstances are similar to the OP. I am a working adult, I can remember going to the theater in the summer of '77 to see Episode IV, I play LOTRO so I am familiar with F2P. etc... While I certainly don't want to see a cash store upset game balance (particularly endgame balance) in SWTOR, I do think BW would be wise to make some of the more mundane necessities like consumables and crafting boosts, as well as cosmetics, available for real money. My play time is fairly limited by real life obligations, so I guess what I am hoping for is "pay to not have to spend my time grinding".
But then you have serious resentment among the playerbase. Sure it may take x amount of hours to get war hero gear but you know what thats so easy compaired to the Campain gear grind. I could see the *working class* as you seem to call yourself asking for a way to buy campain tokens so you have a chance to participate in the new hard mode ops that come with Makeb. I don't think thats fair to the playerbase or yourself.

If you just buy the gear it has no meaning. You didnt earn it. You didnt have to work with your guild to learn that strats to completing content to get said item. It cheapens the whole experiance. It trivializes everyone elses hard work. Dealing with bugs server lag player dissconnects on top of it as well.

I could see you buying stat boosts that are temporary. That would help out the guild your with to complete content, but you still should have to actually get the gear the same way everyone else does.
I played EQ1 for 5 years never made max level. I only played the game 3 hours a day max except weekends. I still had fun. When I did finally get the carrot it felt so amazing. To cheapen that by just purchasing that is just wrong and unfair to yourself and the rest of us...
Fear leads to Anger
Anger leads to hate
HATE leads to suffering

cerveau's Avatar


cerveau
08.22.2012 , 04:00 AM | #106
using this "I havnt got enough time so just gimme all the goodies now" is a crock and you know it.

so its right to negate all the rewards earned by players who actually play the game.
in that case why not have a magic button in the cartel shop that actually plays the game for you
so you never have to log in.

so its right is it ?, that when new content is rolled out, the actual players of the game spend weeks
getting the tokens to buy these items, while the P2W'rs go out and buy all the gear on day 1.

how is that leveling the play field ? it isnt

Fornix's Avatar


Fornix
08.22.2012 , 04:17 AM | #107
Quote: Originally Posted by heydiddlediddle View Post
Can I QQ for you a little?

Personally I like earning items in game, it's part of what makes it fun for me. Not that I have a huge objection to people buying the same items I guess, but it kinda depends. I mean lets say it takes me months of doing dailies or something to earn gear needed to do some raid/PvP/whatever content, and someone else pays like $40 and gets the stuff the very first day.

So like I know we're both in the same gear and everything in the end, but if very few people are interested in doing the content by the time I earn my gear (old content is so old...) my months of dailies were a waste. It's kinda like you were betrayed by a hidden P2W system, which can almost be worse in my mind.

I mean, I know its a grey area and all, but still I'm not sure that would be much fun; well just a thought. :\
If by the time you hit that content, it is no longer of interest (taking PvP considering as to how I as stated do not believe people should buy the latest raid tier gear, considering as to how imo that doesn't make sense) to play those warzones, then those warzones are dodge and of not high enough quality. The grind towards it then is then nothing more than a grind to make up for time in between patches.

Whilst in reality the quality of the warzones should be aimed for being at such a level that years after release, they remain interesting to play, in a similar fashion as to how people can still play the same maps over and over in their favorite FPS and RTS games.




Quote: Originally Posted by cerveau View Post
using this "I havnt got enough time so just gimme all the goodies now" is a crock and you know it.

so its right to negate all the rewards earned by players who actually play the game.
in that case why not have a magic button in the cartel shop that actually plays the game for you
so you never have to log in.
The problem is that in current MMO's, the content is only there at endgame.

PvP wise, it makes little sense to aim to play competitive against players with different levels of actual ingame skills, as well as different gear. Rather than player skill you're simply letting an upper hand in statistics do the work. It's like playing poker against someone who by default gets handed 3 aces.

So a quick way up to the endgame level of pvp could yield a lot of interest.



Additionally, raiding is where it's at for many players, but the grind toward it is not. 10 years ago, major group content which formed the early form of current raiding used to be available at all levels. The term endgame, was practically non-existing. It was the same as early-game and mid-game for that matter. It was a time in which an MMO had no end. People called it grind because of the exp requirements per level, but quickly forgot that those levels did come with plenty of choice in content.

These days you got levels with no challenging content, a pure grind up to cap, then a grind for gear, before you can start raiding. So why, if all you were ever interested in in MMO's was the challenging content, should players be forced to go through that grind over and over?


Publishers can either do two things: start reintroducing challenging content early on ingame; either by a sort of sidekicking system where you get boosted to raid like stats and levels are no longer of any importance; or by simply creating lower level raids. Or by chipping in on their own profit and allowing people quick access to what they actually truly want to be doing in this MMO.
Member of <Helix>

Uwel's Avatar


Uwel
08.22.2012 , 04:31 AM | #108
A thought about "imma hard working man blah" (im a hard working man too). So your excuse is that you don't have the time to gather the gear. It's very funny i think, here's what. You wanna buy tier 1 gear coz you don't have time to gather it. But what's the point when you "can't" go and gather tier 2 with it? Or you just want to stand all day at the fleet and show "look what i have, screw you"...

I hope bioware put some watermark onto those items. "Look that gear, it's frickin' awesome. Let's inspect: "bought on 2012.11.23", then we just run around and laugh"

Sorry, I don't want to be rude, but that's ridiculous
"Imperial intelligence operatives are clearly just as deadly as their Sith superiors."

Bloodstealer's Avatar


Bloodstealer
08.22.2012 , 04:31 AM | #109
Quote: Originally Posted by Murder_Toys View Post
,,, you guys do know that , one of the new guys from BW said blue armour and such are going to be aceessable via the cash shop .

for levels 1 to 49 . ..

yes that does nt effect end game but a person whos just leveling slowly and can t be arse to do the FPs can just buy gear ( blue armour) thats pay to win. in its self..

maybe not effect level 50s but all this talk ...I AM GOING TO QUIT IF I SEE P2W ANYWHERE,,

Needs to grow up , your not going to quit the game your going to piss and moan on a form.. thats any it

face facts .
Well if you think Blue proto armours/weapons are important from 1-49 then I guess that's your take on P2W.. personally I see no need for anything other than the trash stuff you pick up off of every dead mob.. so if idiots want to pay real cash for something that isn't of any tangiable benefit through the leveling experience.. all power to them, hopefully there idiocy will help pay for the next content update.

I have no issues with F2P or cashshops, heck I might even buy some new dayglow hairsyle or a pair of rose tinted glasses but yes... I say NO! to P2W period.. those that are willing to go that route in order to play a game likely need all the help they can get anyway.
The Chaotic Misfits Guild.
Death or Glory - It's all just a game to me!

Referral Link - http://www.swtor.com/r/Mf4BzX

Fornix's Avatar


Fornix
08.22.2012 , 04:42 AM | #110
Quote: Originally Posted by Uwel View Post
A thought about "imma hard working man blah" (im a hard working man too). So your excuse is that you don't have the time to gather the gear. It's very funny i think, here's what. You wanna buy tier 1 gear coz you don't have time to gather it. But what's the point when you "can't" go and gather tier 2 with it? Or you just want to stand all day at the fleet and show "look what i have, screw you"...

I hope bioware put some watermark onto those items. "Look that gear, it's frickin' awesome. Let's inspect: "bought on 2012.11.23", then we just run around and laugh"

Sorry, I don't want to be rude, but that's ridiculous
Raiding doesn't take a lot of time, an hour or 6 a week can be enough. So why, for an hour or 6 a week of raiding, should one first have to grind about 120 hours to reach the level cap and initial gear requirement? That's 20 weeks someone could have used on doing what they like doing best, raiding.

The same can apply to endgame PvP.
Member of <Helix>