Guild Progression Ranking

Strokety stroke. Thats why.

For some people, achieving things in a game with lackluster starter content is very important (as evidenced by the people fighting for it).

I assume at some point bioware will implement some sort of armory, and get all this worked out. Until then, enjoy beating off into each other's eye sockets.

Just to be clear because I think my ADD might have made my previous post a little confusing.

1) I don't expect there to be a nerf to points after a nerf to content. They SHOULD work out end the end. The problem is that they AREN'T currently on the site. I'm confident that in 1.2 they will take care of themselves, though.

2) I think the end boss should have a higher value NOT because it's harder, but because it should signify a complete clear. Granted this gets a little sloppy once we get Nightmare and you can do bosses 1-3 on Hard and then #4 on Nightmare. I still think it should be worth more. Again, not because it's harder. I agree that J&S is harder in 16 nightmare than Karagga.

3) I REALLY like that you have kept all of the rankings completely separate. 8 & 16 are completely separate, normal hard & nightmare are completely separate.

I think overall the site looks great and has a lot of potential to be the kind of tool a lot of us were looking for. Thanks for the hard work and for putting up with all of our needy requests

Edit: OH! Feature request! I'd like to be able to delete my comments on kills.... I might have gotten overzealous and went to confirm some Methodical kills and hit Submit like 43 times because it didn't look like it was "thinking."

Give me the system for assigning values to kills that works in every single branch case and deals with all achievements and unforeseeable changes to the game in the future. How do you quantify that one kill is worth 1100 and another is worth 1150? I guess the argument that a system that at least has an objective aspect is "hurr durr" when compared to system that subjectively conjures up new numbers for every boss is lost on me.

I understand where you are coming from and we are considering this, but understand where we are coming from: If we start assigning points how you want it, there's just going to be someone else childishly complaining that that point system is "hurr durr".

You're welcome to roll your own site for your own system. It's a big internet and no one says that this is all there has to be. We're definitely not opposed to improvements, but it's a difficult path to navigate. I hope you can appreciate that.

That totally sounds painful, and conjures images of a RedRider BB Gun.. count me out!

Only speaking of NMM. Not an HM translation.

I think the first part will work itself out if BW decides to implement a better achievement system, including but not limited to meta achievements that are capable of being tracked and time stamped (COUGH COUGH BW) for encounter clears.

To your second part, I absolutely agree!

You took in 2 members, we raid with 10-12 people from the original nox imperius.

They are our kills, why somad?

edit: you want to claim our EV nightmare kills, wait a sec, which POV is the world first annihilator kill from? Mine and Ookini? ok. thanks

I have no urge to claim Nox Imperius' kills. Troll harder.

You still think double damage crits is a well thought out mechanic Gramz?

ffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff ffffff lolwut

Reading comprehension ftw?