Please upgrade your browser for the best possible experience.

Chrome Firefox Internet Explorer
×

East/West or Right/Left?

STAR WARS: The Old Republic > English > PvP
East/West or Right/Left?

MartyrLXXVII's Avatar


MartyrLXXVII
03.01.2012 , 02:59 PM | #221
Quote: Originally Posted by Armaso View Post
A fact is not an opinion.
The argument is which is better, that is opinion.

East/west may never be wrong technically but it doesn't mean everyone knows where you mean without looking at the map.

Left/right is pure instinct, problem is not everyone understands its based on spawn point, which should be common sense.

So which is more intuitive, knowing the point of reference, or knowing knowing the directional orientation of the map. Sine one requires common sense and one requires use of the in game map the strictly more intuitive one is left/right.

But again, its all opinions.

TheBigBee's Avatar


TheBigBee
03.01.2012 , 03:00 PM | #222
Quote: Originally Posted by Armaso View Post
I could, quite easily and I'm sure someone else will. It just pains me that you can't see it. It's very sad.
LOL avoidance.....
PUT YOUR HELMET ON !!!

TheBigBee's Avatar


TheBigBee
03.01.2012 , 03:01 PM | #223
Quote: Originally Posted by MartyrLXXVII View Post
The argument is which is better, that is opinion.

East/west may never be wrong technically but it doesn't mean everyone knows where you mean without looking at the map.

Left/right is pure instinct, problem is not everyone understands its based on spawn point, which should be common sense.

So which is more intuitive, knowing the point of reference, or knowing knowing the directional orientation of the map. Sine one requires common sense and one requires use of the in game map the strictly more intuitive one is left/right.

But again, its all opinions.

exactly...both are viable and you should know both.....because not everyone will use option A or B or C
PUT YOUR HELMET ON !!!

Armaso's Avatar


Armaso
03.01.2012 , 03:04 PM | #224
Quote: Originally Posted by MartyrLXXVII View Post
The argument is which is better, that is opinion.

East/west may never be wrong technically but it doesn't mean everyone knows where you mean without looking at the map.

Left/right is pure instinct, problem is not everyone understands its based on spawn point, which should be common sense.

So which is more intuitive, knowing the point of reference, or knowing knowing the directional orientation of the map. Sine one requires common sense and one requires use of the in game map the strictly more intuitive one is left/right.

But again, its all opinions.
Common sense would be to use the system put in place many years ago. The orientation of the map is North up. Anyone with common sense knows that. Refer to patch notes if you don't believe BW had the common sense to orient the map correctly.

TheBigBee's Avatar


TheBigBee
03.01.2012 , 03:06 PM | #225
Quote: Originally Posted by Armaso View Post
Common sense would be to use the system put in place many years ago. The orientation of the map is North up. Anyone with common sense knows that. Refer to patch notes if you don't believe BW had the common sense to orient the map correctly.
common sense also dictates Left and Right.....but if you still dont understand left for right well there is not hope for you


as pointed out East and West is also correct use
PUT YOUR HELMET ON !!!

MartyrLXXVII's Avatar


MartyrLXXVII
03.01.2012 , 03:10 PM | #226
Quote: Originally Posted by Armaso View Post
Common sense would be to use the system put in place many years ago. The orientation of the map is North up. Anyone with common sense knows that. Refer to patch notes if you don't believe BW had the common sense to orient the map correctly.
I would agree with that in rl, but why waste the time opening my map so I know which way east is in the game. It's intuitive irl because there are any number of references, not in the game though, in the game the only E/W reference is looking at the map, which is a waste of time.

L/R just is, not outside stimuli needed.

TheBigBee's Avatar


TheBigBee
03.01.2012 , 03:16 PM | #227
Understand and know both....

close thread/
PUT YOUR HELMET ON !!!

Armaso's Avatar


Armaso
03.01.2012 , 03:17 PM | #228
Quote: Originally Posted by TheBigBee View Post
I stated spawn as a reference....it is constant



driving threw the desert tour guide say "look to your left you can see more sand" yup it still works
My first clue as to why you can't grasp this is your use of the word threw in place of through.

So here we are on our desert guide per your example. You are sitting in the front passenger seat and I am sitting in the bed with my back to the cab. The driver says "look to your left and you can see more sand." You look to your left and see more sand. I look to my left and see an oasis.

Had the driver said "look to the East and you will see more sand" we both would have been on the same page.

Point was, roads are rails for cars to drive on. Left right works fine in that structured environment. If we are in the desert and I tell you to head right, which way are you going to go? If I say head East, there is no question.

/thread

Armaso's Avatar


Armaso
03.01.2012 , 03:18 PM | #229
Quote: Originally Posted by MartyrLXXVII View Post
I would agree with that in rl, but why waste the time opening my map so I know which way east is in the game. It's intuitive irl because there are any number of references, not in the game though, in the game the only E/W reference is looking at the map, which is a waste of time.

L/R just is, not outside stimuli needed.

You don't need to open your map. Someone with common sense added a minimap oriented correctly.

jokerxdragon's Avatar


jokerxdragon
03.01.2012 , 03:19 PM | #230
I use East/West, because left/right can be looked at from two different angles so they can wind up being opposite. Someone calls right in Voidstar and you are in the spawn, you are gonna go to your right when they might actually mean left from that perspective. If that makes any sense.