Please, Don't Roll on Items for Another Class in Your Team

"Ok, just to let you all know. You guys can roll Need on medium armor but you can't roll Need on light/heavy armor 'cause I need those"??

As I said, you accused me of ad-hominem. This was not and has not been demonstrable if you make an accusation of a logical fallacy then you have to back it up. You haven't done so. The end.

I think you've been just skimming over people's arguments.

The answer is "No, sorry, you don't get to dictate what people roll on. They get to choose for themselves."

That's kind of the point. Rolls, where everyone chooses whether to roll or not = good, fair, unbiased, impartial.

There is no we. There is just you.

I have, if your comprehension is lacking that is YOUR issue.

So that's not what you guys say when you are social? The "speak up" thingy you all keep mentioning.

Yes.

Is that actually his claim? There is actually a difference between "ad hominem attacks" and "argument ad hominem" and I'm pretty sure he accused you of the former, not the latter.

Diversionary.

LOL, good luck grouping in the future. You'd better hope they put in place a cross server LFFP type feature or you may have to reroll to find a group that will take you in. With my play style, I don't have to worry about it. No one complains when I need for my PC. NO ONE. Can the same be said for your play style? The fact is, the community dictates their own rules and I've played enough of these games to know that your side is seriously playing with fire. You may have 10 groups in a row where you're needing everything in sight with no one saying a word buteventually, when most people won't even respond to your whispers, you'll know exactly why.


These games revolve around gear for most people. Players want better gear to better their game. Heck, the whole end game is based off this concept. If they see you needing on a tank piece for your companion when the tank also needed it, you will hear about it. And hey, it's their right. Your decision to loot gear that was created with their class in mind was an insult to their play style just like their blasting you in gen chat/in their guild is an insult to you. You have a right to play your way and they have a right to play theirs.

Don't take offense, he says that to everyone. If you Google "Strawman" you will find his picture next to the definition, too.

You're right. I accused you of ad hominem. You said the accusation wasn't accurate. I told you to show me my error and prove how your previous post wasn't ad hominem. You copy/pasted a definition rife with editorial commentary that ate away at any objective facts it might have contained.

But at no point did you actually prove your post wasn't an ad hominem attack. I even went so far as to point out how it was, something you've yet to refute. In fact, you keep dancing around the refutation, which leads me to think you don't actually have a defensible rebuttal to begin with.

I was speaking mistakenly. ..post edited.

My apologies to Eldren.