No, You May Not Roll on Items for Another Class and Strip Out the Mods

So someone who prioritizes looks over stats is wrong? They are playing wrong? So you get to decide this? The orange item system ENCOURAGES customizing your looks. What right do you have to tell them they are playing wrong?

My wife will happily take lower stats on something she prefers the appearance of. That's what's important to her when she plays. With disrespectful comments like this, were we ever unfortunate enough to encounter you in game I can guarantee we'd spare you the slot on your ignore list, and happily take care of that for you.

Why is it so utterly impossible for you to show the least bit of respect to someone who might have a different playstyle than you do?

Good job quoting only the definition from dictionary.com that supports your argument. Here are the others.

2. legitimately sought, pursued, done, given, etc.; proper under the rules
4. neither excellent nor poor; moderately or tolerably good

For (2) we are discussing the merit of the rules. And for (4) my opinion is different than yours.

Doesn't this strike you as a sign that maybe your view is not such a widely assumed one, if you are afraid to broach it.

Looks don't you take down that gold in that quest you're trying to complete. Better stats do. Make sense?

Ok I understand now.

Here's the issue though, while yes if you base your opinion on what you see on your server, you may come to a given conclusion, based on your observation.

However your observation of a subset of the whole is inherently suspect because you aren't getting data from a wide range of people. On my server, Kath Hound a RP server, people are going to have different priorities and opinions then people playing on a PvP server, or even a PvE server.

On the message boards, because it does attract a wide range of people from different types of servers, you're going to find a better sample group.

I've seen more then one person say that people who feel it's ok to need for companions are a very small, even meaningless minority. However based on the posts I've seen, that doesn't seem to be true at all. I can't give a % of those for and those against, but it's clear that neither side is a massive majority (80% or higher) of the player base.

And? Just because you prioritize killing Elites or Champions doesn't mean they do. They just want to look cool or whatever. So, still looking for why you get to decide for them.

BH wearing Sith robes? Wrong.

Jedi wearing smuggler hat? Wrong.

Smuggler wearing Inquisitor robes? Wrong.

It's a cop out to say that orange gear is up for grabs. It's whoever needs it, then whoever can wear it, then whoever wants it. That's how it goes.

In this case, you are referring to loot I assume. That be so, there is no detriment to the group at all. The entire group are doing whatever they are doing so they all get a chance at loot.


The common good is quite irrelevant. And even if it were, who is to decide it? You? It takes some ego to assume you know more about what I need than I do myself. Your whole argument fails right there.

And who are you to decide anything for me? I can make my own decisions. I do not need you to decide for me. When you finally reach the understanding of that, you will understand that what you attempting to do, is dictate to others your terms and conditions.

And neither is the fanatical adherence to the ideal that your needs and ideals have any leverage over mine.

Your Logic is not sound, sir. In fact, it's down right ridiculous. Playing dress up is fun and all, but it won't help you while questing. Stat boosts will. Nice troll attempt though.