Please upgrade your browser for the best possible experience.

Chrome Firefox Internet Explorer
×

[POLL] Damage Meters


Baastila's Avatar


Baastila
01.22.2012 , 11:45 PM | #41
Quote: Originally Posted by Sai-to View Post
No group wipes on a boss in an Operation for 2 hours just because of one person. Flashpoints can be wiped because of only one person, but only if that person is a bad Tank or Healer.
This kind of attitude is exactly what the poster you responded to is disgusted by. People will see someone doing 10% less damage than someone else, and immediately blame them for any problems, usually resulting in a kick.

While it's very true that you should blame the user, not the tool... certain tools act as ENABLERS of horrible behavior. Real-time meters are one of those. Personally, when I see group leaders kick someone for being slightly less "par" than another, I put the leader on my /ignore list then leave the group as well. Unfortunately... it makes you fill up your ignore list REALLY fast.
There is something called enrage timer. Tanks and healers don't cause that. You can't tell a tank or a healer "do more damage".
Quote:
The class that defeats me is OP, the class that I defeat is right where it should be, the class I play is always underpowered.
IRRELEVANT LINK, DON'T CLICK!

Baastila's Avatar


Baastila
01.22.2012 , 11:46 PM | #42
Quote: Originally Posted by Bossalinie View Post
No, he is saying he is tired of needledicks blowing gaskets over 100 dps. If you are wiping over that, then DM won't fix your problem.

Obviously he is the selfish one because Bioware decided not to put DM in the game, right?
So you are saying who cares how much dps a person does, right? Since dps really isn't a concern.
Quote:
The class that defeats me is OP, the class that I defeat is right where it should be, the class I play is always underpowered.
IRRELEVANT LINK, DON'T CLICK!

Valethar's Avatar


Valethar
01.22.2012 , 11:46 PM | #43
Wow, look at all the elitist estrogen all over the place.

Amazing how something like this can make all the trolls froth at the mouth. And people wonder why there is so much hate towards meters.
"Due to the massive loss of subscribers in our flagship title, we decided to cancel Blizzcon this year, because frankly, we don't think there's anyone left who would show up."

Belgaer's Avatar


Belgaer
01.22.2012 , 11:47 PM | #44
Not sure on this one. People would have their cookie cutter party/operation setups for Flashpoints and Operations and then classes that aren't ideal would get the shaft. Pretty sure a DPS Assassin (my main) wouldn't fit it because it's not retardedly easy to play like some other DPS classes are. So the class would be considered "not as good" and then shunned, when it actually has potential to be better if played right. I've seen it in other MMOs and I seem to have a tendency to pick classes like this...

RipVanWinkleX's Avatar


RipVanWinkleX
01.22.2012 , 11:47 PM | #45
no no no no

Arctorius's Avatar


Arctorius
01.22.2012 , 11:47 PM | #46
Quote: Originally Posted by Baastila View Post
There is something called enrage timer. Tanks and healers don't cause that. You can't tell a tank or a healer "do more damage".
QFT

Furthermore most damage meters record more than damage. Things like Damage Taken and Dispels can be very helpful. If the boss has something that needs to be dispelled and only one person is getting rid of it, acknowledging that issue and resolving it is that much easier.
My 2 cents

Baastila's Avatar


Baastila
01.22.2012 , 11:49 PM | #47
Quote: Originally Posted by LogicalPremise View Post
Hint: Casuals don't raid. Never have.
Hint: Low DPS on DPS classes is pretty obvious.

Damage meters are the first step toward the people with more ePeen than skill gaining the upper hand. Again -- when I have to be geared better than gear I can get in a Raid to join the raid, then the system is borked.

Having participated through NM raids, I'm thinking if you're still wiping at this point, you're just all pack of bads. We've (the community) cleared almost everything without any tools to speak of at all (except Soa, but he's buggier than an ant nest, so no surprises there).

If you're a bad, and can't put together a competent group, just simply go back to playing Normal Mode and find other bads and tell yourself you're a "leet". I promise everyone will be laughing at you.
So you are saying people who are more dedicated to raiding should carry less skilled players through contents since "leet" players shouldn't exist?
Quote:
The class that defeats me is OP, the class that I defeat is right where it should be, the class I play is always underpowered.
IRRELEVANT LINK, DON'T CLICK!

Kabjat's Avatar


Kabjat
01.22.2012 , 11:49 PM | #48
Quote: Originally Posted by Baastila View Post
You do more dmg/healing under 2 conditions:

1)More skill
2)More gear

You can be as skill as you want to be, but you ain't gonna beat somebody in Rakata gear with 50's leveling gear. That being said, if 2 players with same gears, the one doing more damage obviously is more skilled (under MOST conditions).

I'm not saying people who don't want a DM are all bad at the game, what I'm saying is that they shouldn't be afraid to have a DM. Without a DM, nobody knows if they are doing good damage or bad. It is also used to evaluate which spec works better. No matter how much they balance the game, a specific spec is going to be better than another one, it is as simple as that.
Then maybe you should keep the aggression out of your posts. This is a hot button issue and when you say things like,

If you are casual, and can't pull your own weight in a more "pro" group, just simply leave the group and find like-minded people and wipe for 5 hours, I promise you nobody will then b*t#h at you.

you are likely to have people assuming you are part of the problem. I myself am FOR damage meters being allowed in-game, but I can CERTAINLY understand the sentiment of those who DO NOT wish for them. It's people like you who get rabid and start screaming at how badly they suck and in general making assumptions about them.
Quote: Originally Posted by Thaltom View Post
Are you playing TOR on an Atari Potato?

Keihryon's Avatar


Keihryon
01.22.2012 , 11:51 PM | #49
Quote: Originally Posted by Baastila View Post
You do more dmg/healing under 2 conditions:

1)More skill
2)More gear

You can be as skill as you want to be, but you ain't gonna beat somebody in Rakata gear with 50's leveling gear. That being said, if 2 players with same gears, the one doing more damage obviously is more skilled (under MOST conditions).

I'm not saying people who don't want a DM are all bad at the game, what I'm saying is that they shouldn't be afraid to have a DM. Without a DM, nobody knows if they are doing good damage or bad. It is also used to evaluate which spec works better. No matter how much they balance the game, a specific spec is going to be better than another one, it is as simple as that.
It's not fear, if it were fear I imagine my eyes would be wider. ~Simon Tam

I'm not going to debate this with you because you firmly believe they are needed, while I don't. You won't change my mind and I won't change yours. I'm not afraid of meters, despite what you'd like to think, I just don't think they are necessary and usually tend to ruin gameplay for people like myself. Those who enjoy playing by learning through doing, and not being told.

TJixlee's Avatar


TJixlee
01.22.2012 , 11:51 PM | #50
no ty
SWTOR: Achievments

CE Member----SWTOR Tester