Please upgrade your browser for the best possible experience.

Chrome Firefox Internet Explorer
×

Why did Mace Windu & Co. attack Palpatin

STAR WARS: The Old Republic > English > Story and Lore
Why did Mace Windu & Co. attack Palpatin

Solzean's Avatar


Solzean
01.11.2012 , 03:14 PM | #61
Quote: Originally Posted by Midasear View Post
Sure. But this is a _fun_ troll.
Fair enough. Its not a troll if the trolled person is having fun. Which...in that case...

The troll has a fair point. In my opinion Mace Windu Probably as in fact doing the wrong thing by trying to kill Palpatine one he was defeated. Whether or not it was a trick, Windu should have NOT attempted to kill someone who was essentially surrendered by begging for help. That and I have heard that Windu's style was very close to the dark side as it was, so I dont doubt he was under the dark sides influence even more at that point. Palpatine could very well have been sitting there influencing him to break the Jedi Code.

DaShuk's Avatar


DaShuk
01.11.2012 , 04:01 PM | #62
Quote: Originally Posted by Midasear View Post
They had no defense. Palpatine killed everyone but Mace Windu within seconds, and only pretended to be vulnerable to Windu to convince Anakin to break with the Jedi. Palpatine was at the height of his powers, a master manipulator, and could see into the future. Do you think he would have risked exposure to the Jedi if he had not been absolutely certain of his ability to butcher them in a direct confrontation? The entire encounter was staged for Anakin's benefit, with the added benefit of building public animosity toward the Jedi.

Mace Windu might as well have wrapped Anakin & the Galactic Republic up in a box with a ribbon and fedexed it to the Sith. It ultimately doesn't matter if you're in the right or in the wrong if you're being played.

Why did Mace Windu try to arrest Palpatine? Ultimately, the right answer is "Because he behaved exactly how Palpatine thought he would."
Pretended to be vulnerable to Windu? Somehow I doubt that, Mace would have ended his life if Anakin hadn't acted like a total idiot and been swayed by the dark side.

HeyImOkko's Avatar


HeyImOkko
01.11.2012 , 05:19 PM | #63
It's simple. The Jedi knew there was a 'Darth Sidious' who controlled the entire Separatist movement, thanks to Count Dooku. As soon as Palp confessed to Anikan to be that sith lord, he immediately told the second strongest and in power jedi he could find, Windu. Now knowing someone that powerful is also in control of the Galactic Rep. he couldn't possible wait till the next morning to arrest him, let alone in public to make a scene. He takes a team with him to arrest Palp, he strikes.
That's it.
Not because he wasn't a jedi, but because he was the dark lord they were looking for who was in control of the Separatist, not to mention the treason charges.
Nothing more.

HeyImOkko's Avatar


HeyImOkko
01.11.2012 , 05:21 PM | #64
Quote: Originally Posted by DaShuk View Post
Pretended to be vulnerable to Windu? Somehow I doubt that, Mace would have ended his life if Anakin hadn't acted like a total idiot and been swayed by the dark side.
Mace Windu was the Master Of The Order right before the Clone Wars, and himself created numerous lightsaber fighting forms. He would've taken Palp down then if Anakin didn't interfere.

smalloy's Avatar


smalloy
01.11.2012 , 07:16 PM | #65
.........This troll got 5 pages of replies? Ok, Anakin told Mace Windu of the plot of the Emperor against the Senate. They went to arrest him for being a criminal, not for being the Dark Lord of the Sith. Palpatine attacks them, Mace whoops the Chancellors rear, Anakin being the wuss he was in the prequals, saves the Chancellor, becomes Darth Vader.

The End

Gnatjulio's Avatar


Gnatjulio
01.11.2012 , 08:25 PM | #66
Quote: Originally Posted by Ilmor View Post
Yes. And Count Dooku tried to murder Palpatin (at least the jedi thought so).



So, why would they remove him from his office? Because he has the wrong religion?
and anakin slaughtered younglings because they were the wrong religion. but you think palpatine is a victim.....lol.

Grilltusk's Avatar


Grilltusk
01.11.2012 , 09:46 PM | #67
Does the OP have no idea what being a Sith stands for?
Ofcourse they needed him arrested. But Mr Sidious decided to go all lightbaery-butcher on mr Windu.

This not just a religion issue. Its what the Sith are responsible for, have done and will keep on doing if left unchecked that validates everything Windu did.

Grilltusk's Avatar


Grilltusk
01.11.2012 , 09:51 PM | #68
Quote: Originally Posted by jimee View Post
a better question is, instead of trying to arrest Palpatin in his private office at night, why did Mace not confronted the dude in broad daylight or during a public senate meeting?

Doing this would expose Palpatin to the general public, saving the Jedi from order 66 going through and preventing the rise of an empire.

Way to think this one through master jedi
Rewatch the movies.
If the crowd would find out the Jedi order, those that are present to protect them didnt notice earlier a freaking Sith Lord had taken the position Palpatine had, they'd get a lot of problems on their hands. hence taking him away from the prying eyes of the public.

Giondi's Avatar


Giondi
01.11.2012 , 10:05 PM | #69
Quote: Originally Posted by Ilmor View Post
So he was a enemy of republic not because of something he has done but because his religion is evil (or at least the leader of an other religion said so).
That's the very definition of religious persecution.
That's like calling religious persecution when someone is arrested while actively trying to blow up a plane. At this point in the Star Wars galaxy, Sith is not a force user who is not a Jedi, it is a conscious choice that you want to be the embodiment of the Dark Side. Traditionally, a Jedi would fight any Sith he met with the intent of killing the Sith, Mace and the others just wanted to bring him in under suspicion of treason. So really, it's more like a cop witnesses a crime in progress, asks if he could ask some questions, the criminal shoots the cop, and then people cry religious persecution.
Quote: Originally Posted by Bedwarmer View Post
Dear Dps; I assure you that you were, in fact, nowhere remotely close to "One heal from soloing it."
Every MMO forum in under 30 seconds.