Please upgrade your browser for the best possible experience.

Chrome Firefox Internet Explorer
×

DPS meters cause abuse and take away choice!

STAR WARS: The Old Republic > English > General Discussion
DPS meters cause abuse and take away choice!

IreScath's Avatar


IreScath
01.11.2012 , 11:24 AM | #61
Quote: Originally Posted by DarthGrimmlokk View Post
Let me tell you a little story. While my guild was raiding ICC we had a DPS DK in the group who raided consistently and as a result had top end gear, however after each fight she was always in the bottom third of DPS. With the gear she had, she should have been in the top 2-3 for DPS. However, and this is the very important point...we cleared everything!

Now, were we carrying her? I guess you could look at it like we were, and I'll be honest, because of having recount there were days I felt annoyed. This is my POINT, with no recount I wouldn't have felt any annoyance at all because we were CLEARING the content. This person was a consistent raider who always showed up on time, and was enjoyable to raid with. Does this person need to be removed? I would say no.
And my point.. is that the people actually pulling their weight and take the time to do the best they can, do not deserve to have to carry such a player.

And what if you weren't clearing stuff? (btw ICC was the easiest tier of content ever created in WoW at the time) What if you had no recount and your raid didn't have the dps?...

What then?... Call the raid and go home?... No. I'd rather know what or who the issue is.... fix it... and continue.

dmg meters plz k thx
Darth Raiden <Attack Move> - The Twin Spears (Empire)

Mehetmet's Avatar


Mehetmet
01.11.2012 , 11:25 AM | #62
When the game becomes work--having to figure out the way to max dps, look up the "proper" and perfect rotations, perfect talent with maybe 1 or 2 flex points--it is no longer fun.

Having the meters will undoubtedly result in one spec rising above the others and becoming the only acceptable way to do endgame.

This doesn't mean I'm going to try to dps as a healing spec, it means hey there are 2 damage trees, i'm picking the one thats more fun for me to play.

Mertissielle's Avatar


Mertissielle
01.11.2012 , 11:25 AM | #63
Quote: Originally Posted by DarthGrimmlokk View Post
Let me tell you a little story. While my guild was raiding ICC we had a DPS DK in the group who raided consistently and as a result had top end gear, however after each fight she was always in the bottom third of DPS. With the gear she had, she should have been in the top 2-3 for DPS. However, and this is the very important point...we cleared everything!

Now, were we carrying her? I guess you could look at it like we were, and I'll be honest, because of having recount there were days I felt annoyed. This is my POINT, with no recount I wouldn't have felt any annoyance at all because we were CLEARING the content. This person was a consistent raider who always showed up on time, and was enjoyable to raid with. Does this person need to be removed? I would say no.
What if you hadn't been clearing the content? What if you'd spent a month and a half on the same boss, always wiping at sub 5%? What if you realised that everyone was doing near to their theoretical maximum for their gear aside from one person? Great to ignore it when you're clearing content (and I agree, you should do) but when you're not and you're facing an entire team of angry people who are beginning to leave for other guilds or get restless and tetchy and snipe at each other on Vent week after week? That's a bit different.

Galbatorrix's Avatar


Galbatorrix
01.11.2012 , 11:25 AM | #64
Quote: Originally Posted by DarthGrimmlokk View Post
Let me tell you a little story. While my guild was raiding ICC we had a DPS DK in the group who raided consistently and as a result had top end gear, however after each fight she was always in the bottom third of DPS. With the gear she had, she should have been in the top 2-3 for DPS. However, and this is the very important point...we cleared everything!

Now, were we carrying her? I guess you could look at it like we were, and I'll be honest, because of having recount there were days I felt annoyed. This is my POINT, with no recount I wouldn't have felt any annoyance at all because we were CLEARING the content. This person was a consistent raider who always showed up on time, and was enjoyable to raid with. Does this person need to be removed? I would say no.

Well of course they should have been removed. They're the weak "link". Never mind the fact that you're having a good time and succeeding. It's all about who pulled what. Not how much fun you're having. People that play these games like they're a job need to get their priorities straight.

Aramyn's Avatar


Aramyn
01.11.2012 , 11:26 AM | #65
Quote: Originally Posted by Valcutio View Post
Tell me how all those epics from WoW are treating you in SWTOR? Oh... wait.
w/e you want to call them. I'm decked out in full purples in swtor and absolutely destroy other people. Its pretty boring actually.

DarthGrimmlokk's Avatar


DarthGrimmlokk
01.11.2012 , 11:26 AM | #66
Quote: Originally Posted by Mertissielle View Post
Rotface/Festergut were pretty much gearchecks. Especially whichever one of those two was the one with spores.
Okay, of course you have to do some minimal level of DPS to kill any boss, however neither of those bosses were necessarily DPS races where someone's lack of ultimate DPS was the cause of the wipe in most cases. In most cases raids wiped, not because of a lack of DPS, but because someone didn't pass the ooze off or stood in the spore cloud at the wrong time. That is my point.

Quote:

Valithria was also essentially a tank and spank with a gearcheck race component, it's just that it was HPS rather than DPS that was being tested.
Again, the healing was important, but more often than not, at least in the raids I was in, people would wipe mostly because the adds were not picked up and killed appropriately.

Quote:

I skipped Tier 11 so I can't say for certain if there was a DPS check boss there, though it'd surprise me if there wasn't. There certainly was in Tier 12 (Baleroc) and there is in Tier 13 (Ultraxion).

So, yeah. It's a mechanic that's existed in basically every tier of raiding in WoW and I suspect such bosses will be present here, if for no other reason than they gate the progress slightly and extend an Operation's lifespan.
As I said, DPS is important of course, however more often than not the cause of a wipe has nothing to do with player X doing 2% less dps than they are capable of and much more because Player X didn't get out of the defile when they were supposed to. You don't need DPS meters for those problems which are the main causes of raid wipes.

IreScath's Avatar


IreScath
01.11.2012 , 11:26 AM | #67
Quote: Originally Posted by Warjhinn View Post
Sooo you agree that if I engage in a form of entertainment, like a video game, and I do not play it your way, than I am lazy? The people that take that kind of stuff seriously need to find another obsession or they are the kind that this is a business to them. The developers need to take it seriously, but the gold farmers/hackers need to go away and quit ruining my FUN!!!

This is a game/hobby/entertainment to most people.
Ok so?... My hobby is downing content in an MMO. Dmg meters ensure that we have to weak dps... So that I can accomplish what I set out to do as my hobby.

Are you judging me personally for wanting that?.. Because that is what it sounds like.
Darth Raiden <Attack Move> - The Twin Spears (Empire)

Teront's Avatar


Teront
01.11.2012 , 11:27 AM | #68
Selfish selfish selfish.

7 other people should suffer because I can't do what's expected of me. That is essentially what is being said with this no meters argument.

I have never ever used meters to harass anyone.

I have used them to better my raid to see who may need help and try to help them. If they can't accept my help because they are to selfish or can't press buttons fast enough, I have 7 other people in the operation to think about. 7 people should not suffer for one persons lack of learning skills.

I'm sorry if you can't accept that then you don't belong in operations. It's the price to play.

Scorpassailant's Avatar


Scorpassailant
01.11.2012 , 11:27 AM | #69
Sounds like the OP has been kicked off a few raids in wow for not having good enough dps. Well..join the club. It happens.

Galbatorrix's Avatar


Galbatorrix
01.11.2012 , 11:28 AM | #70
Quote: Originally Posted by Mertissielle View Post
What if you hadn't been clearing the content? What if you'd spent a month and a half on the same boss, always wiping at sub 5%? What if you realised that everyone was doing near to their theoretical maximum for their gear aside from one person? Great to ignore it when you're clearing content (and I agree, you should do) but when you're not and you're facing an entire team of angry people who are beginning to leave for other guilds or get restless and tetchy and snipe at each other on Vent week after week? That's a bit different.

If they add recount, you better hope that the spec you like the most is the DPS king for your class. Otherwise, I'd hope that you'd don't have to group with half the elistist people in this thread.