Jump to content

Ahsoka Tano fate?


Asacado

Recommended Posts

I read the book.

 

 

Ahsoka Tano died from Order 66 because at the time (according to the movies as well) she was being trained by Master Yoda. Anakin Skywalker aka Darth Vader killed them (including ahsoka tano).

 

No..... That Togruta you saw in Episode II is a boy. And even if it was her....that would make her like 7 when she appeared in TCW movie which was like maybe 2 to 1 year after Attack of the Clones.In the film and the Series up until later seasons she was like 12 or 14?

 

The Clone Wars only takes place for 3 Years....3 Loooong years....wait....How are they cramming all these stories into the time period of 3 Years? Not to mention TCW takes place like on the last two years. It's kind of confusing really. Especially considering Star Wars Years are shorter than ours by a few months if I'm not mistaken. Hmm...maybe they will retcon it from 3 Years to 5 or 6 Years or probably make their years a lot longer?

Edited by CassusVerda
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 60
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

No..... That Togruta you saw in Episode II is a boy. And even if it was her....that would make her like 7 when she appeared in TCW movie which was like maybe 2 to 1 year after Attack of the Clones.In the film and the Series up until later seasons she was like 12 or 14?

 

The Clone Wars only takes place for 3 Years....3 Loooong years....wait....How are they cramming all these stories into the time period of 3 Years? Not to mention TCW takes place like on the last two years. It's kind of confusing really. Especially considering Star Wars Years are shorter than ours by a few months if I'm not mistaken. Hmm...maybe they will retcon it from 3 Years to 5 or 6 Years or probably make their years a lot longer?

 

No, you may have just figured out why Anakin REALLY snapped. Sleep Deprivation.

 

They kept him running from battle to battle, with hyperdrives getting them from one point to the next in minutes, thanks to some obscure lost technology, and Obi Wan neglected to teach him how to live on no sleep, so that's why he was so screwed up on the third movie!

 

As for Ahsoka, since Anakin didn't learn the live on no sleep trick, she couldn't learn it, so she just ended up sleeping through the entire third movie, and order 66, and woke up a few month later feeling really embarrassed. There, everything explained! :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No, you may have just figured out why Anakin REALLY snapped. Sleep Deprivation.

 

They kept him running from battle to battle, with hyperdrives getting them from one point to the next in minutes, thanks to some obscure lost technology, and Obi Wan neglected to teach him how to live on no sleep, so that's why he was so screwed up on the third movie!

 

As for Ahsoka, since Anakin didn't learn the live on no sleep trick, she couldn't learn it, so she just ended up sleeping through the entire third movie, and order 66, and woke up a few month later feeling really embarrassed. There, everything explained! :D

Can I buy space pot from you?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My theory is that she's going to leave the Jedi Order for love. It seems in TCW that they are building a relationship between the Seperatist kid and her. I think this would be the only way for Anakin to "let go" of her, since he can relate to doing something for love.

 

 

I agree with the idea she leaves to get married, this would no longer make her a Jedi and would mean she could still be alive when all the Jedi are killed. This would effect Anakin even more as he would see her leaving as a betral. The only argument is in ROTS he quotes her by saying, here's where the fun begins which she said to him in the Clone Wars film, which someone who had killed or felt betrayed by someone else wouldn't do.

 

I don't think we will see her in any books set after ANH until this question has been answered in the series.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree with the idea she leaves to get married, this would no longer make her a Jedi and would mean she could still be alive when all the Jedi are killed. This would effect Anakin even more as he would see her leaving as a betral. The only argument is in ROTS he quotes her by saying, here's where the fun begins which she said to him in the Clone Wars film, which someone who had killed or felt betrayed by someone else wouldn't do.

 

I don't think we will see her in any books set after ANH until this question has been answered in the series.

In this day and age of technology, I'm sure they could extend that scene of Anakin in the ship by a few seconds and make him look slightly upset after saying it. You never know.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

In this day and age of technology, I'm sure they could extend that scene of Anakin in the ship by a few seconds and make him look slightly upset after saying it. You never know.

 

HEHE yeah and re re re release it at the cinema :D oh and then there's that thing about vertical filming on mobile phones, Lucas would have to remake the entire trilogy in Vertical format :p

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 7 months later...
  • 1 month later...
I really believe that she needs to be in episode 7. Due to her being a major part in Anakin's life, she is most likely one of the Jedi that gets the warning message that the "War is over" at the end of Epi 3 being false and going into hiding out where ever she may go. Possibly after Anakin/Vader's Death she feels her former master is dead and will come out of hiding to possibly return to the Jedi order. I hope she will help Luke and Leia train there children in the ways of the force just as Anakin trained her. She can have a major roll in Epi 7 and hopefully be apart of the new republic and new Jedi order.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Having Ahsoka survive the entire Dark Times is the worst idea since inflatable dartboards. To have her crop up in Episode 7 would be stretching the viability of plot armor incredibly thin. She's a nice character, but she needs to die in the Clone Wars. It would break continuity far too much otherwise.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Having her die is foolish, in my opinion. She isn't a Jedi anymore, there is no particular reason why she would be targeted unless she does something stupid. I think it would be far more poignant for her to survive and witness the deaths of her former friends and colleagues and deal with the psychological ramifications of having abandoned them, however justified she may have been. I do not think she should be in Episode 7 (though I would not object either) as I'd prefer her to stick to her guns and have nothing to do with the Jedi.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

She dies. I know this because everyone dies eventually.

 

Yoda: “Death is a natural part of life. Rejoice for those around you who transform into the Force. Mourn them do not. Miss them do not. Attachment leads to jealously. The shadow of greed, that is.”:csw_yoda:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

By then she would be pretty old, since Luke, Han, and Leia are probably gonna be all the old people, and Ahsoka would be almost 20 years older than Luke, not sure how life-spans work in Star Wars though.

I would prefer her to just die sometime in the 3-4 gap, or be in something where she is still young and learning stuff, her with Ventress would be pretty cool :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

She was born around 35BBY so by the time of Endor she would be around 39/40 which isn't particularly old by our standards. But of course the sequels are set at some point after that, 20-30 years at a guess. Still not necessarily a handicap as we have no idea how togruta age.

 

Having said that, I don't particularly want to see her in the films.

Edited by LadyDrusilla
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Considering that Anakin was barely even a Knight when he turned Sith, he never could have had a padawan*** and therefore ahsoka never ACTUALLY existed... just saying...

 

EDIT: To clarify with the *** above:

He never could have had a padawan with the jedi during the clone wars...The idea of him having padawans between eps 3 and 4 isn't so far fetched (a lot can happen and be swept under the rug in 20 years) but the 2-3 years between eps 2 and 3 isn't enough time to do all that was "done" in the "Clone Wars" TV series and still have no real evidence of it in the movies...

 

considering the movies came straight from GL, if he didn't mention it, it either A) wasn't important enough to be mentioned, which Anakin having an apprentice would definitely be noteworthy; or B) didn't happen to begin with.

Edited by LordFailstrom
clarification
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anakin was a full Jedi Knight in EP 3, he wasn't barely he was.

 

I'd call that up for debate, still being escorted everywhere by Obi-Wan at the time, but regardless the point still remains that any "apprentice" had by Anakin would've been mentioned in the movies...that's not something that gets "swept under the rug" and since it wasn't mentioned, there is no reason to believe such an apprentice ever existed...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'd call that up for debate, still being escorted everywhere by Obi-Wan at the time, but regardless the point still remains that any "apprentice" had by Anakin would've been mentioned in the movies...that's not something that gets "swept under the rug" and since it wasn't mentioned, there is no reason to believe such an apprentice ever existed...

 

Just because he was with Obi-Wan doesn't mean he wasn't a knight, they were a perfect tag team. He was knighted, and infact he was really only a Knight in title, in skill he might aswell have been a Jedi Master. Though to the apprentice thing....you gotta remember, ROTS came out before TCW series so of course there is gonna be no mention of an apprentice, I don't see there really have been a need to bring up Anakin having an apprentice anyway.

Edited by Wolfninjajedi
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anakin having an apprentice is as stupid an idea as bringing Darth Maul back from the dead. But don't mind me, I'm still mad about them killing Chewbacca off in the EU.

 

But it took a *********** moon to kill him! How could you be mad, that it took a MOON to kill Chewie?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just because he was with Obi-Wan doesn't mean he wasn't a knight, they were a perfect tag team. He was knighted, and infact he was really only a Knight in title, in skill he might aswell have been a Jedi Master. Though to the apprentice thing....you gotta remember, ROTS came out before TCW series so of course there is gonna be no mention of an apprentice, I don't see there really have been a need to bring up Anakin having an apprentice anyway.

 

That's the thing, it's a really painful retcon to swallow, since it just shows that not enough thought was given to Anakin's character when the prequels were being written.

 

Honestly, the prequels had a great story seed, the potential was there to tell this epic tale of Anakin's fall as a Jedi Knight, but the delivery fell flat on its face. Those films deserve to be remade down the road, incorporating and integrating the entirety of the Clone Wars and the backstory to Phantom Menace so that everything meshes and we can appreciate the story that George meant to tell us with the films.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That's the thing, it's a really painful retcon to swallow, since it just shows that not enough thought was given to Anakin's character when the prequels were being written.

 

Honestly, the prequels had a great story seed, the potential was there to tell this epic tale of Anakin's fall as a Jedi Knight, but the delivery fell flat on its face. Those films deserve to be remade down the road, incorporating and integrating the entirety of the Clone Wars and the backstory to Phantom Menace so that everything meshes and we can appreciate the story that George meant to tell us with the films.

 

While right, i'll admit I was surprised at first at Anakin having a padawan. Though...to note, the movies just showed the start of the Clone Wars and then the end, so I don't really see the problem that Anakin could have had a padawan during the course of the war and something happen. But in the grand scheme of things of what was going on, there wasn't really any point to bring up Anakin having an apprentice, sure there was no mention of him having one....but at the same time there wasn't any mention that he didn't have one.

 

Thus leaving it open, to explain in TCW show that he did. The movies are just one part of the SWU, it tells and goes through the points that need to be made the other things can be sorted out in other aspects. You can't just rely on movies, to tell and detail everything otherwise you'd have such long movies. I mean in ESB, you only saw a portion of Luke's training and then he suddenly went to go fight Vader....when infact he actually trained for much longer then just a few days.

Edited by Wolfninjajedi
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anakin having an apprentice is as stupid an idea as bringing Darth Maul back from the dead. But don't mind me, I'm still mad about them killing Chewbacca off in the EU.

 

Everyone dies, mate. I'm glad that he went out with a bang, it brought some mortality to the characters from the film. But yeah, Darth Maul coming back was worse than Boba Fett. At least Fett died off-screen, under ambiguous circumstances. Darth Maul got sliced in half and fell down a thousand foot reactor shaft! That's more than it took to kill Palpatine.

Edited by Ventessel
Link to comment
Share on other sites


×
×
  • Create New...