@Orlogg or should we open a new thread ?
You're free to open a new thread of course. Make sure to think of a better (less ambivalent, less multi-interpretable) title than I did!
I suspect many people who come here and write a reply, just read the title and/or some posts, while the points/objections they bring up are already addressed and/or explained/corrected. Of course, that can be expected when a thread begins to grow. For the thread starter, that is frustrating!
Too bad I can't close the thread.