So am hearing a lot of whoa is me, gimme loot cause I deserve it for beating the payment boss, where is my medal for participation.
This line made me giggle because the guy you quoted actually had a pretty logical and well-stated argument, yet your response is this pile of refuse. Some of the new nightmare fights are most certainly not "easy mode", unlike the way the HM versions were when they were released. So your comparison of nightmare mode to getting a gold star for showing up is completely off base.
You know a lot of these issues could be solved if bioware would actually release HM at the same time as Nightmare.......would satisfy all levels of raiding guilds. But as someone mentioned earlier, content is released at a snail's pace so either the "hardcore" guilds will get bored or the "casual" raiding guilds will be bored.