Scenario #2: PUG's are so poorly organized that they literally lose the game for the 4 man pre-made. Pre-made loses what should have been an easy win.
Stopped reading here, you're just as bad as the people whining about pre-mades if not worse. "I came in with a 4-man team, but we still lost, my teammates are BADS"
Nope sorry, if you come in with a 4-man team, you can't blame your teammates for a loss, it's cause you're not good enough. A PUG that blames his teammates is being a self-righteous whiner, and a member of a pre-made that does the same thing is too.