Well, make both then? And let the subscribers on the forums decide which one they would rather have for free, the other would be on the CM and tradeable and therefore available to everyone.
I see you make items and weapons and blasters all the time with the cartel packs. How about take some of the really cool ones out...make a poll and ask the forum members (or poll voters) which one they would like as a gift....because all forum members are subscribers right? And keep the other ones in game....still...available to everyone.
Will you stop trying to make everything about Subscriber Exclusivity? Get over it. You weren't born special. You will probably never be special. You will probably be average like everyone else in the world. Deal with it like everyone else does who wanted to be special and never did.
Force your children into show business and live vicariously through them!