What if your opponent is actually perceptive and DOESN'T use their first cc right away? What then? You can't force them to cc you while your defensive cds are up.
There is no best tactic in pvp, we can theorycraft about what the opponent is going to do to counter the max resolve tactic but there are too many possibility when a human being is playing and not a AI.
Melee vs melee, melee vs range, range vs range and tank/dps/heal roll difference plus different class ability.
L2P. Know your class and their class.