Hmm, this isn't the first time that mistake has been made so I suppose I should clarify. The player pools for cookies and Goof are fairly different. Myself, Psibre, and occasionally Vullesh and Sarah are pretty much it. Other than that cookies has quite a few lowbies in Goof, and a couple 50s that rarely get played and vice verse with goof players in cookies. Not that it really matters, if any of those listed guilds show up in regs its a win unless another one shows up on the other side. From there much more has to do with the pugs then the differences in ability between the guilds.
Dammit Asuna. You beat me too it.