I personally think it's a good idea the whole concept behind this thread. Yes, I also think it may fail. It may not. It all comes down to the players and how they respond.
Although throwing negative into the situation is not helping. Even you are stating the obvious. I'm pretty sure the majority of us are able to see what the hell is really going on.
Also imho if you don't have the balls to que up without your guild then you should have no say as to what this thread is all about. Why do you need your guilds to steam roll pugs? If you are as good as you think you are you should have no issue pugging.
Despite having my issues with combatmedicjr I think it's great he's standing behind this as much as he is. At least until it goes full force and he jumps back to full guild runs again