Definitely the Old Republic hilt from SWG. Curved, golden hilt... on my ex's account, I decked all her equipment out... she used an old republic hilt with unlayered battle armor (meaning 6000 to all protections, next best thing to a master jedi cloak) in Mk3 Crusader armor (gold) with matching cape, ... looked menacing as hell.
Drede Shadow... I miss ya, darling
Also, the Jinsu Razor... sweet hilt, very simple yet sooo... attractive.
here's a lightsaber gallery from Galaxies