View Single Post

Kitru's Avatar

11.23.2012 , 12:51 PM | #3
It's not really a new spec since a lot of people tried to check it out when Infiltration was first tweaked when 1.4 landed. The "gain" in survivability isn't really there and you're paying for it by drastically decreasing your threat generation.

It's important to remember that Blackout has a CD of 60 seconds, which means you're getting roughly 10% uptime (this can get marginally higher by factoring in the entry Shadow's Respite and use of Force Cloak, which I wouldn't really since it's a complete threat drop and any time you'd have the opportunity to do that without screwing your group, you don't need the DR). 25% mitigation with 10% uptime translates to 2.5% additional DR. At 40% K/E DR, 2.5% additional DR translates to a 4.3% decrease in damage taken. Slow Time, expressly as a damage reduction mechanism, is more valuable than what you're getting out of Blackout, not to mention that you're losing out on Psychokinesis (which means that you're also hurting your Force maintenance by costing 2 more Force with every DS and 6 more with every Project) and Upheaval (which means your Project is hitting substantially lighter than it would be otherwise). It's also important to remember that the talents that you're taking to get up to Masked Assault are largely useless to a Shadow Tank (Infiltration Tactics is useless when you should be the focus of a boss and never get to see its backside; Security Breach is of marginal use at best especially when compared to losing Slow Time which does more damage, generates more threat, and is on a shorter CD; Misdirection and Celerity are only useful in PvP).

On a side note, Vigor is pretty much entirely useless to you as it is to every Shadow spec that exists. 10 additional Force is functionally worthless when you should be spending all of your time below 50 Force, and the only Force generation benefit you'd be getting out of it is getting 6.6 Force from DBSD rather than 6 (which, as I said before, is substantially less than you'd get out of Psychokinesis and Slow Time).
Walls of Text? I *love* Walls of Text!
My New Class Idea
Shadow Class Rep - Suggest/Review Questions Here
Quote: Originally Posted by Fende View Post
Listen to Kitru. Kitru knows all.