Just thought I would make everyone aware and ask what people thought? Fair? Exploit? Should I have reported?
I can understand why they did it, and you don't know what kind of bad experiences with ninjas might have driven them to it. If their guildie needed, assuming they did so honestly and for their main spec, then by saying you wanted it for off-spec you were admitting you didn't need it as much. It was a bit rude, to be honest, and our guild wouldn't appreciate members doing that sort of thing, but you weren't stiffed out of gear by your own admission. If it bothers you, put them on ignore, or check their website and email their GM.