Personally, if Lucas would stay out of the production and writing, and let BioWare tell the story in three full length Animated Features
, they would be epic. Not a live action film. LA tends to restrict the writers and directors from really showing what they want people to see as they have envisioned it, without the restrictions of physical actors going through the motions. Animation allows you to push all the boundaries without the potential for injury or interruptions. It lets them include things and add more effects that could be made for a LA film. Nevermind the constant moving and building of sets and moving from one location to the next.
Let me say this. When you take an American concept and then have it done with Eastern Animation styles, it generally looks INCREDIBLE!
On the reverse side though, when you take an Anime/Manga and let fricken Hollywood try and make it into a live action, it turns into a giant steaming load of crap.
Speed Racer: Great old anime back in the day. Horrible movie.
G-Force: Originally it was 5 People in bird-like spandex costumes controlling vehicles that merged into one air-craft and fought against invading extra-terrestrial forces and was originally called Gatchaman by the creator, Amano Yo****aka. It was also called "Battle of the Planets" prior to being simply called G-Force when brought to America. Hollywood turned it into freaking GUINEA PIGS!!!
Avatar -The Last Airbender-: ...do I even need to explain this abomination?
I think my point is clear.