Yes. I have an alt with Underworld Trading that has gotten me like a dozen of the things. But when I give them to her it says +0. Yet, I know she is courtable. Am I waiting for a trigger?
Is she is over 5000 affection points you'll need lvl 3 or better gifts to get anything.
Someone had a nice list 0-3999, 4000-5999 etc but I can't find it. Also you have to get one flirt in first before most companions like them at all.
Someone correct me if I am wrong.