It doesn't matter if it irrational or not. If you don't like it, then do yourself a favor and quit reading it. Its obvious from the post that its a complaint. If you love the game so much just go and play it.
As for him comparing it to wow it is valid, just because you guys have some sort of "us vs them" mentality doesn't all of a sudden make your point valid. He has every right to ask for anything he wants and you guys coming in and telling him to go away is in fact rude and insulting. Who died and made you the MMO pope?