I couldn't agree more. I've played PvP in several other games and currently SWTOR pvp is pretty broken. I hope they fix it soon. As a Sith Juggernaut, I literally want to turn off the game or wipe my toon after playing PvP. I don't do enough damage to kill anybody, I spend my whole time CC'd or knocked back, and even though I'm supposed to be (according to BW) "an unstoppable force of Darkness," I spend more time standing in one place than moving. In WoW (and YES I know this is a different game but BW CLEARLY took a page from Blizzard's playbook) as a Protection Warrior I could have 2-6 guys on me and still be moving around and interrupting them; basically making their life hell. Did I die? Of course! But did I sometimes kill one of them in the process, yes. Did I sometimes hang onto the flag JUST long enough for my teammates to respawn and get most of the way back, absolutely. In SWTOR, as soon as a couple enemies engage me I am locked down and dead within almost no time... I feel completely worthless.
I don't mind dying, honestly. I don't mind losing. But I am really, really bothered by feeling helpless and worthless. BW, please take a look at pvp and, if necessary, take another page out of Blizzard's playbook. Or even EQ2, which I still think had some wonderful pvp. If you want 'your own' style, your own pvp system, then rebuild the whole thing b/c it's already too similar to pvp we've seen before to be considered next generation.