Or maybe it encourages the other people below them that their rotation/gear isn't working and they need to spend some time getting better?
Unless you know who is sub-par, all of the DPS will get blamed for the failure if everyone stays alive but still hits enrage. Personally, I would rather know when I am holding the group back so that I can improve rather than get removed from the group permanently.
We've all sucked at these games at some point, and to get better, we had to know we sucked.
How are we going to know when we, personally and not the group, suck without damage meters?