I think you better check first if you really play in this server, Tomb of freedon nadd. Just that all posts you have written in topic.... None of those have anything to do with this server.
Actually having played against them in rwz and judging by that it seems they are doing ok.
Of course they have a lot to learn to be competitive but there is some potential
Yes, if you can call few forum trolls "guild fights". Mostly I think it actually is pretty good community if you look at the big picture.
Same goes for republic as well, afterall most people have max lvl characters on both sides.