After reading the OP I wouldn't want to be in his guild. Is this how the community will greet it's newest members? Threats of banishment from the guild if they talk about things one or two members of a guild hierarchy don't like.This community is rather intolerant to begin with. If something is said that someone doesn't like or agree with, your branded a troll or some other nasty name. And secret notes begin to pass between the so called offended person and the Mods. Next thing you know demerits are doled out, warnings issued and threats of banned accounts. All because someone thinks the world revolves around them.
I would rather remain guildless than have to deal with such oppression.
Bioware doesn't need to lay down the law, some people need to grow a thicker skin.